• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Reinstatement of James Watt statue with plaque explaining "dark side"

Status
Not open for further replies.

adrock1976

Established Member
Joined
10 Dec 2013
Messages
4,450
Location
What's it called? It's called Cumbernauld
I stumbled upon an article from the Daily Telegraph that mentions that the statues of James Watt, Matthew Boulton, and William Murdoch that were put into storage for the Midland Metro works in Birmingham, will be put back on show but with a plaque explaining their "dark side" in the involvement of the slave trade.

Weblink to the article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/20...atue-will-reinstalled-plaque-explaining-dark/

Here is the article in its original form below:

James Watt’s statue will be reinstalled – with plaque explaining ‘dark side’ of ‘golden boy’​

When it reappears in Birmingham, combined statue of Watt and other pioneering engineers will incorporate text documenting links to slavery

ByCraig Simpson11 June 2021 • 10:00pm

James Watt, a Scottish inventor and mechanical engineer, was renowned for his improvements in steam engine technology

James Watt, a Scottish inventor and mechanical engineer, was renowned for his improvements in steam engine technology, although an element of his father's income was derived from colonial trade CREDIT: Getty

James Watt’s statue will be reinstalled after being reviewed during Black Lives Matter protests in Birmingham, but will the addition of a plaque explaining the "dark side" of the inventor and links his to slavery.
Watt produced steam engines in Birmingham which powered the Industrial Revolution, and he was honoured alongside colleagues Matthew Boulton and William Murdoch with a gilded statue in the city known locally as “the golden boys”.
Despite the monument being in storage, Birmingham City Council identified it as at “possible risk” due to Watt’s family connections to the slave trade in a review of statues drafted following Black Lives Matter protests.
Watt’s gilded statue will be taken out of storage and reinstated in the city centre, but it will be given a plaque explaining the “dark side to the story of the Watt family”.
The dossier of “at risk” statutes compiled by the council during BLM protests states: “Watt's family and Watt himself were not only complicit in the slave trade, they participated directly and benefited extensively from the profits that slavery generated.”
BT4YJF Golden Boys of Birmingham Statue, showing Boulton, Watt and Murdoch , Broad Street, Birmingham, England, UK.

The so-called 'Golden Boys of Birmingham' statue, showing Boulton, Watt and Murdoch CREDIT: Alamy Stock Photo
It adds: “His father paid for Watt's education; an element of his father's income was from colonial trade.”

The document seen by The Telegraph also notes on 'the golden boys' that: “Both Boulton and Watt sold steam trains for slave plantations in the Caribbean. Murdock, as an employee, framed by association.

The statue of Watt, Boulton, and Murdoch was originally placed in storage in 2017 during works on the Metro system, and has remained in storage while works continue on the refurbishment of Centenary Square.
When reinstalled, the statue of the three men will be contextualised with information “which the Council requested in order to provide information for a new information plaque”, as well as online background on the documented links to slavery.
This will use a specific piece of academic research on "James Watt and his links to slavery" commissioned by the Birmingham Museums Trust.
Born in Scotland, Watt developed a steam engine which improved on earlier designs by being cheaper and more efficient, providing a readily available source of power for manufacturers in the Industrial Revolution.
In 1775, he went into business with Boulton, and the Boulton & Watt firm was established to make and sell these engines.
The company itself has come under scrutiny regarding its capital investors, some of whom had links to the slave trade. Research suggests that while Boulton and Watt also sold engines to the Caribbean, they may have believed this reduced the need for slave labour.
The statue of the two men and their colleague Murdock may not be the last to be reinterpreted by Birmingham City Council. It is understood the local authority is seeking to “engage in a wider conversation with residents and the public about heritage, injustice, inequality and multicultural citizenry".
“This will include a review of the appropriateness of local monuments and statues on public land and council property.
“The Council will also ensure that other plaques accompanying our monuments properly and fully explain their historical context where appropriate.”

Will this move help to reduce the possibility of the statues being torn down in the future similar to how the Colton statue was torn down in Bristol last year?
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

LSWR Cavalier

Established Member
Joined
23 Aug 2020
Messages
1,565
Location
Leafy Suburbia
Good idea I think. There has been talk about re-naming streets, but I think we should remember history so we may learn from it. Have any highways been named after Margaret Thatcher yet?
 

Iskra

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2014
Messages
7,894
Location
West Riding
Good idea I think. There has been talk about re-naming streets, but I think we should remember history so we may learn from it. Have any highways been named after Margaret Thatcher yet?
How far do we go though? Most historic figures and cultures had a dark side, you’d need a lot of explanations.

And will the ancestors of the Vikings, Arabs, Barbary pirates, Romans, Normans etc be doing similar for enslaving and conquering British subjects previously...
 

AlterEgo

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Dec 2008
Messages
20,167
Location
No longer here
If the only reason the text is being added is to prevent illegal vandalism from happening then that speaks about all sorts of priorities being wrong with society.
 

Iskra

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2014
Messages
7,894
Location
West Riding
If the only reason the text is being added is to prevent illegal vandalism from happening then that speaks about all sorts of priorities being wrong with society.
I don’t think adding any text will deter mindless vandals anyway. They will just find another excuse to retrospectively cover their actions.
 

IanXC

Emeritus Moderator
Joined
18 Dec 2009
Messages
6,335
Good idea I think. There has been talk about re-naming streets, but I think we should remember history so we may learn from it. Have any highways been named after Margaret Thatcher yet?

The big one for me, is when streets are renamed in this context (because I can't imagine there won't be any renamed) the new street signs must state what the previous name is. Otherwise the history is lost, and doing this will preserve not only the history some would say is lost in these circumstances, but highlight the change and the reasons for it.
 

102 fan

Member
Joined
14 May 2007
Messages
769
What annoys me about the BLM protests is that during the troubles in N Ireland 3,532 people from both sides were murdered and 47,500 were injured, without any similar protest in USA or GB.

Where does this end with statues, or is it only statues were the victims were black?
 

johnnychips

Established Member
Joined
19 Nov 2011
Messages
3,675
Location
Sheffield
I have just read the top article about Watt, and it wasn’t him involved in the slave trade, but possibly his dad. Now that is going too far.
 

yorksrob

Veteran Member
Joined
6 Aug 2009
Messages
38,938
Location
Yorks
Yes, Watt shouldn't be blamed for the sins of his father. However as a principle, I don't have a proplem with plaques explaining peoples dark sides. It's preferable to wholesale removal of monuments.

If anything, one dark side of industrialists of that era that ought to be explained might be the conditions in their mills and craftsmen put out of business and forced to work long hours in factories etc.
 

C J Snarzell

Established Member
Joined
11 Apr 2019
Messages
1,506
Without going too much off topic, many of our historic leaders have their 'dark sides' and are not popular with everyone. It doesn't necessarily have anything to do with slavery.

Coming from a family of miners, Margaret Thatcher was hated in my Grandmother's house for obvious reasons. Thatcher destroyed communities and plunged thousands of people into poverty.

Tony Blair is hated by many who felt his handling of the Afghan/Iraq wars was both criminal and inhumane.

CJ
 

DarloRich

Veteran Member
Joined
12 Oct 2010
Messages
29,276
Location
Fenny Stratford
it isn't about dark or light sides. It is about historical fact and accuracy. Should we not have context and information so we can make a rounded judgement about an individual?
 
Last edited:

birchesgreen

Established Member
Joined
16 Jun 2020
Messages
5,128
Location
Birmingham
it isn't about dark or light sides. It is about historical fact and accuracy. Should we not have context and information so we can make a rounded judgement about an individual?
No because then people might not come up with the correct judgments. :p
 

WelshBluebird

Established Member
Joined
14 Jan 2010
Messages
4,923
Will this move help to reduce the possibility of the statues being torn down in the future similar to how the Colton statue was torn down in Bristol last year?
I'd expect so - given part of the history of the Colston statue was local politicians failure to properly engage with the local community (some politicians tried, and a new plaque was going to be created, but the local merchant ventures and Tories watered down the wording so much it was basically just a duplicate of the existing plaque anyway).
How far do we go though? Most historic figures and cultures had a dark side, you’d need a lot of explanations.

And will the ancestors of the Vikings, Arabs, Barbary pirates, Romans, Normans etc be doing similar for enslaving and conquering British subjects previously...
And what is wrong with having "a lot of explanations"? Surely we should learn about all aspects of our history, good and bad?
I don’t think adding any text will deter mindless vandals anyway. They will just find another excuse to retrospectively cover their actions.
Agreed. But be careful to assume that people are mindless vandals - the stuff in Bristol for example had a long history of it coming way before BLM and the like.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top