• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

TOD collections onboard?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Argyle 1980

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2020
Messages
166
Location
Cornwall
When I was attempting to collect some tickets from Plymouth to Folkestone yesterday morning, I experienced the anomaly a lot of people seem to experience about not having a physical card as I'd purchased with PayZilch (an interest free Klarna type platform) but in the form of a virtual Mastercard in their app as unlike Klarna they don't have check out facilities directly with retailers. Obviously the physical card doesn't exist so tried using my Barclaycard but it refused it. Asked the staff at the help desk about it as the queue at ticket office was absolutely ridiculous. There was somebody I assume was a train manager or ticket examiner with them and he said "I can retrieve them for you" and proceeded to get his machine out of his bag and a few minutes later he had printed all my tickets off for me from the collection reference without a card.

My question is can all onboard staff now do this? Or is it something they can actually do but not something TOCs like doing?
Also the tickets had Aztec QR codes on them. Kind of reminder EastCoast doing that too back when they were around.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

LowLevel

Established Member
Joined
26 Oct 2013
Messages
7,544
Goes very much against the idea of have your tickets before you board our train.

It depends on your work environment I suppose.

My own TOC enabled it years ago for guards and revenue protection although with the move to online ticketing it does get far less use than it did.

The rationale was twofold - firstly it meant that if the TVMs and booking offices crapped out at some or all locations rather than just allowing travel with reference numbers you could print the tickets.

Secondly we had, and still have (though there's a programme to correct this in most but not all locations) a large number of stations without TVMs that still attract feeder traffic into long distance services. There often wasn't much time for them to collect their tickets at interchanges and the company policy for these stations was to allow travel on reference numbers so again it would be good customer service for the guard to print the tickets and also reduce spurious refunds of "unused" tickets should they make it to the other end without collecting.

On the other hand if you serve mostly or entirely stations with ticket facilities it becomes a less useful feature.

I remember some mornings when the old Parkeon Northern machine at Dore had died heading to Manchester I'd go through the train collecting 15 or 20 reference numbers to print off en masse during a phone signal area and deliver to seats for people. Same from Liverpool South Parkway in the mornings.
 

skyhigh

Established Member
Joined
14 Sep 2014
Messages
5,220
It depends on your work environment I suppose.

My own TOC enabled it years ago for guards and revenue protection although with the move to online ticketing it does get far less use than it did.

The rationale was twofold - firstly it meant that if the TVMs and booking offices crapped out at some or all locations rather than just allowing travel with reference numbers you could print the tickets.

Secondly we had, and still have (though there's a programme to correct this in most but not all locations) a large number of stations without TVMs that still attract feeder traffic into long distance services. There often wasn't much time for them to collect their tickets at interchanges and the company policy for these stations was to allow travel on reference numbers so again it would be good customer service for the guard to print the tickets and also reduce spurious refunds of "unused" tickets should they make it to the other end without collecting.

On the other hand if you serve mostly or entirely stations with ticket facilities it becomes a less useful feature.

I remember some mornings when the old Parkeon Northern machine at Dore had died heading to Manchester I'd go through the train collecting 15 or 20 reference numbers to print off en masse during a phone signal area and deliver to seats for people. Same from Liverpool South Parkway in the mornings.
I wish we had the option to use it with our discretion, but as you say they decided against it given the plan was for every station we serve to have TVMs capable of printing them (not that that helps when they've been vandalised so many times at certain stations it's been decided not to replace them...)
 

Wolfie

Established Member
Joined
17 Aug 2010
Messages
6,050
It depends on your work environment I suppose.

My own TOC enabled it years ago for guards and revenue protection although with the move to online ticketing it does get far less use than it did.

The rationale was twofold - firstly it meant that if the TVMs and booking offices crapped out at some or all locations rather than just allowing travel with reference numbers you could print the tickets.

Secondly we had, and still have (though there's a programme to correct this in most but not all locations) a large number of stations without TVMs that still attract feeder traffic into long distance services. There often wasn't much time for them to collect their tickets at interchanges and the company policy for these stations was to allow travel on reference numbers so again it would be good customer service for the guard to print the tickets and also reduce spurious refunds of "unused" tickets should they make it to the other end without collecting.

On the other hand if you serve mostly or entirely stations with ticket facilities it becomes a less useful feature.

I remember some mornings when the old Parkeon Northern machine at Dore had died heading to Manchester I'd go through the train collecting 15 or 20 reference numbers to print off en masse during a phone signal area and deliver to seats for people. Same from Liverpool South Parkway in the mornings.
I have been critical of TOCs in the past but this sounds like sensible, even enlightened, passenger-friendly decision making.
 

Argyle 1980

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2020
Messages
166
Location
Cornwall
Goes very much against the idea of have your tickets before you board our train.
Ultimately the only way to negate this is to remove the requirement of having to insert the card used into the TVM. I suspect some TOCs see it as a means to stop anyone trying to blag a journey on a reference number, or actually having a genuine booking and then refunding it if they don't get asked by the inspector.

It also offers a better value ticketing options for people who's local stations have neither a TVM or office and have to have expensive walk up fares forced on them through no fault of their own.

It depends on your work environment I suppose.

My own TOC enabled it years ago for guards and revenue protection although with the move to online ticketing it does get far less use than it did.

The rationale was twofold - firstly it meant that if the TVMs and booking offices crapped out at some or all locations rather than just allowing travel with reference numbers you could print the tickets.

Secondly we had, and still have (though there's a programme to correct this in most but not all locations) a large number of stations without TVMs that still attract feeder traffic into long distance services. There often wasn't much time for them to collect their tickets at interchanges and the company policy for these stations was to allow travel on reference numbers so again it would be good customer service for the guard to print the tickets and also reduce spurious refunds of "unused" tickets should they make it to the other end without collecting.

On the other hand if you serve mostly or entirely stations with ticket facilities it becomes a less useful feature.

I remember some mornings when the old Parkeon Northern machine at Dore had died heading to Manchester I'd go through the train collecting 15 or 20 reference numbers to print off en masse during a phone signal area and deliver to seats for people. Same from Liverpool South Parkway in the mornings.
Some of the connections in from Falmouth and Penryn are very tight at Truro for the North bound services so obviously if tickets can be collected onboard now, then it's a far better option than say a dozen people all with the idea of trying to retrieve their tickets at Truro during the interchange.
To be honest I'm very surprised Falmouth and Penryn don't at the very least a TVM given the large number of students there. It would also enable GWR to make them penalty fare stations as I know they lose a hell of lot of ticket revenue from those stations.
 
Last edited:

skyhigh

Established Member
Joined
14 Sep 2014
Messages
5,220
Some of the connections in from Falmouth and Penryn are very tight at Truro for the North bound services so obviously if tickets can be collected onboard now, then it's a far better option than say a dozen people all with the idea of trying to retrieve their tickets at Truro during the interchange.
The basic rule is that you need to hold the ticket to travel - that's why when you book a ticket to collect it asks you to select the station you wish to collect from to ensure there's a machine there. If the machine is broken, you'll likely get shown discretion onboard. If there's no machine, or there is one and you don't use it, you might find yourself being treated as not having a ticket. There's certainly no rule that you'll be able to collect your tickets onboard if you don't at the origin station.
 

Argyle 1980

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2020
Messages
166
Location
Cornwall
The basic rule is that you need to hold the ticket to travel - that's why when you book a ticket to collect it asks you to select the station you wish to collect from to ensure there's a machine there. If the machine is broken, you'll likely get shown discretion onboard. If there's no machine, or there is one and you don't use it, you might find yourself being treated as not having a ticket. There's certainly no rule that you'll be able to collect your tickets onboard if you don't at the origin station.
Meant more towards where the TVM refuses to give tickets out when the card used to purchase them cannot be inserted, because it doesn't exist.

What’s that got to do with it?
If someone buys a ticket in good faith thinking they can collect it with any card, which is definately allowed by some TOCs or machines, but not allowed by others.
I'm sure the bulk of regular passengers have no idea this anomaly exists when buying with a virtual Visa or Mastercard, and that they'll be unable to collect their tickets in these circumstances.
As these types of cards are starting to become more and more common than physical cards are, these isn't this the time for the industry to do something. Can't imagine it would be that difficult for the merchant system to identify these cards by their BIN number and warn that these cards cannot collect tickets.
Seem to vaguely remember the old fast tickets machines (pre chip and pin I think) not being able to take non standard cards (example mint cards) which the corner was shaped differently and a warning was issued by the merchant when a BIN number identified such a card whilst purchasing.
 
Last edited:

alistairlees

Established Member
Joined
29 Dec 2016
Messages
3,725
ToD is on its way out. No-one's going to be spending money changing stuff. All retail sites say: "you will need the same card as you paid with to collect with", though PayPal, Apple Pay etc. of course mean 'any card' collection. Some stations and on-board staff can issue ToD too, sometimes overriding the specific card requirement.
 

Argyle 1980

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2020
Messages
166
Location
Cornwall
ToD is on its way out. No-one's going to be spending money changing stuff. All retail sites say: "you will need the same card as you paid with to collect with", though PayPal, Apple Pay etc. of course mean 'any card' collection. Some stations and on-board staff can issue ToD too, sometimes overriding the specific card requirement.
Yes Google pay and warrants allow any card collection but that definitely isn't the case with virtual Visa and Mastercard transactions where the physical card doesn't exist, yet the machines refuse to release the tickets unless the original card used in the purchase is inserted, which the card obviously doesn't exist.

Think TOD being phased out is atleast a generation away yet unless the likes of Southeastern and TFL are forced to accept Etickets and paper roll tickets etc, and judging by my own and other people's communications with SE over the matter suggests it won't be anytime soon as they were adamant they have absolutely no intention of embracing them.
 

Haywain

Veteran Member
Joined
3 Feb 2013
Messages
14,877
Think TOD being phased out is atleast a generation away yet unless the likes of Southeastern and TFL are forced to accept Etickets and paper roll tickets etc, and judging by my own and other people's communications with SE over the matter suggests it won't be anytime soon as they were adamant they have absolutely no intention of embracing them.
Definitely on the way out. TfL may be a problem in the short term but I think the advent of GBR will provide the unified approach the industry has been lacking for the past 25 years.
 

alistairlees

Established Member
Joined
29 Dec 2016
Messages
3,725
Yes Google pay and warrants allow any card collection but that definitely isn't the case with virtual Visa and Mastercard transactions where the physical card doesn't exist, yet the machines refuse to release the tickets unless the original card used in the purchase is inserted, which the card obviously doesn't exist.
Where the card is known - whether it physically exists or not - then "same card collection" should be required from most, if not all, retailers. Virtual cards come in the category of the card being 'known'.

Where the card is unknown - so PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Alipay etc. (these act as intermediaries, so the card cannot be known), there is no choice for retailers to offer anything other than "any card collection".

Think TOD being phased out is atleast a generation away yet unless the likes of Southeastern and TFL are forced to accept Etickets and paper roll tickets etc, and judging by my own and other people's communications with SE over the matter suggests it won't be anytime soon as they were adamant they have absolutely no intention of embracing them.
The remaining TOCs that don't already will accept eTickets / barcode tickets shortly. Solutions for getting across London are being discussed. ToD will be gone in less than 5 years.
 

RPI

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2010
Messages
2,742
We routinely do it on GWR (though less and less) on the branch lines, the official line is it should be collected prior to travel and it can only be printed from our TTK machines if there's not cross London or a travel card involved (unless ita one of the very few and far between sets with a CCST printer)
 

Argyle 1980

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2020
Messages
166
Location
Cornwall
Where the card is known - whether it physically exists or not - then "same card collection" should be required from most, if not all, retailers. Virtual cards come in the category of the card being 'known'.

Where the card is unknown - so PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Alipay etc. (these act as intermediaries, so the card cannot be known), there is no choice for retailers to offer anything other than "any card collection".


The remaining TOCs that don't already will accept eTickets / barcode tickets shortly. Solutions for getting across London are being discussed. ToD will be gone in less than 5 years.
So the bottom line is if somebody pays with a virtual card, then there's a pretty good chance that they will encounter collection problems?

Something I just thought of now though was if somebody linked their virtual card to their Samsung Pay account and had the particular virtual card as the default card on Samsung Pay and then made the purchase through Samsung Pay and when going to collect the tickets, insert the physical Samsung Pay card to see if it works. Unsure if it would work though because even when you pay instore with Samsung Pay either via the device or the physical card, it generates a different card number on every transaction.
 

alistairlees

Established Member
Joined
29 Dec 2016
Messages
3,725
So the bottom line is if somebody pays with a virtual card, then there's a pretty good chance that they will encounter collection problems?
If you haven’t physically got the card, then you won’t be able to collect with it.
Something I just thought of now though was if somebody linked their virtual card to their Samsung Pay account and had the particular virtual card as the default card on Samsung Pay and then made the purchase through Samsung Pay and when going to collect the tickets, insert the physical Samsung Pay card to see if it works. Unsure if it would work though because even when you pay instore with Samsung Pay either via the device or the physical card, it generates a different card number on every transaction.
Is Samsung Pay supported by any retailers? If it is then I expect it won’t be a problem; it will behave the same as Apple Pay. But I don’t know so I can’t be certain.

Basically, if you have entered card details onto the retailer’s website, then you need to have that card to collect ToD. If you have not entered card details directly into the retailer’s website - because you have used an intermediary such as PayPal or Apple Pay that will not pass on card details to the retailer - then you can collect with any card.
 

Wallsendmag

Established Member
Joined
11 Dec 2014
Messages
5,136
Location
Wallsend or somewhere in GB
If you haven’t physically got the card, then you won’t be able to collect with it.

Is Samsung Pay supported by any retailers? If it is then I expect it won’t be a problem; it will behave the same as Apple Pay. But I don’t know so I can’t be certain.

Basically, if you have entered card details onto the retailer’s website, then you need to have that card to collect ToD. If you have not entered card details directly into the retailer’s website - because you have used an intermediary such as PayPal or Apple Pay that will not pass on card details to the retailer - then you can collect with any card.
You can use contactless to start the ToD process on our TVMs so it may work
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
11,648
As these types of cards are starting to become more and more common than physical cards are, these isn't this the time for the industry to do something.
Interesting assertion if that is indeed the case. Can anyone confirm? o_O
 

johncrossley

Established Member
Joined
30 Mar 2021
Messages
2,976
Location
London
Interesting assertion if that is indeed the case. Can anyone confirm? o_O

You can create as many virtual cards as you want. Many people like the idea of having a card number that can only be used once, so they use it for one transaction and then get rid of it. If they want to make another purchase then they get another card number, use it once, then get rid of it again. So even if there aren't so many *people* with virtual cards, the total number of card numbers being used is higher.
 

Starmill

Veteran Member
Fares Advisor
Joined
18 May 2012
Messages
23,224
Location
Bolton
You can create as many virtual cards as you want. Many people like the idea of having a card number that can only be used once, so they use it for one transaction and then get rid of it. If they want to make another purchase then they get another card number, use it once, then get rid of it again. So even if there aren't so many *people* with virtual cards, the total number of card numbers being used is higher.
It's very useful if you want to sign up for a subscription service (such as Netflix) but don't want to commit to more than the first month. That way if you use your first month but having tried it out don't want to keep the subscription, you're protected from your card being charged a second time because you forgot to ensure that you properly cancelled.
 

Argyle 1980

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2020
Messages
166
Location
Cornwall
If you haven’t physically got the card, then you won’t be able to collect with it.

Is Samsung Pay supported by any retailers? If it is then I expect it won’t be a problem; it will behave the same as Apple Pay. But I don’t know so I can’t be certain.

Basically, if you have entered card details onto the retailer’s website, then you need to have that card to collect ToD. If you have not entered card details directly into the retailer’s website - because you have used an intermediary such as PayPal or Apple Pay that will not pass on card details to the retailer - then you can collect with any card.
The virtual card in question is via an app called PayZilch (similar to Klarna) but instead of being directed to that as a payment option on a site, the app instead generates a virtual Mastercard badged debit card which you can reveal a number on if paying online or simply to use as contactless via Google/Samsung Pay if in the actual shop or at a station and it's this particular virtual Mastercard that's caused me the problem as it said it needed inserting.
Samsung Pay is slightly different to Google/Apple Pay as it also has a physical card (Mastercard debit) to back up the NFC payment device on the phone. The card doesn't have any numbers printed on it though, so in order to access these and the cards pin number, they need to be revealed in the Samsung Pay or Curve app, but like I alluded these numbers change after every transaction with the exception of the BIN number (first six digits) which stay the same. A machine couldn't identify someone's card by the BIN alone as it only identifies the issuer within the Visa/Mastercard schemes. Example of this is say Natwest visa debit cards start 4751 followed by either 28 if it's an online full authorization card (basically old Visa Electron) or 29 if it's an offline card.
As you rightly say, most TOCs don't directly take Google/Apple/Samsung online but it is possible to pay via Samsung Pay online via revealing this Mastercard number in the app and entering it at the checkout as if it was a physical card. Again because these numbers are completely randomly generated on each transaction, then a TVM is unlikely to recognise the Samsung Pay physical card as the card used in the transaction and refuse to release the tickets.

That's what the physical Samsung Pay card looks like. See there's absolutely no numbers on it. These can oy be randomly generated when opening the app.
 

Attachments

  • 20210717_225039.jpg
    20210717_225039.jpg
    3.6 MB · Views: 26
  • 20210717_225110.jpg
    20210717_225110.jpg
    2.6 MB · Views: 26
Last edited:

infobleep

Veteran Member
Joined
27 Feb 2011
Messages
12,557
Where the card is known - whether it physically exists or not - then "same card collection" should be required from most, if not all, retailers. Virtual cards come in the category of the card being 'known'.

Where the card is unknown - so PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Alipay etc. (these act as intermediaries, so the card cannot be known), there is no choice for retailers to offer anything other than "any card collection".


The remaining TOCs that don't already will accept eTickets / barcode tickets shortly. Solutions for getting across London are being discussed. ToD will be gone in less than 5 years.
Glad to hear the remaining TOCs will accept them. I hope this extends to TOCs who do issue and accept dtickets but not for all flows that don't involve TfL. I have specifically excluded TfL when I talk about flows not enabled.
 

Argyle 1980

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2020
Messages
166
Location
Cornwall
Somebody correct me if I'm wrong here but didn't London Underground use to accept paper roll tickets in the 90s that had the + marked on them? I'm pretty sure I ended up with them a fair few times in late 90s when it was only quickfare machined at Folkestone Central. I know day travel cards needed to be exchanged at the London Terminal but I'm sure that the + tickets were fine. I also seem to remember the hand written white carbon copy notebook type tickets that revenue inspectors used too use could even mark an + onto it if required as I'd often go to my dad's in Liverpool straight from school on last day of a term and go straight from Sandling Station and I'm sure RPIs got on at Tonbridge once and issued me such a ticket.
 

island

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Dec 2010
Messages
15,982
Location
0036
Yes, PORTIS and SPORTIS onboard machines (in use until about 2006) could not encode the magnetic stripe of tickets.
 

Argyle 1980

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2020
Messages
166
Location
Cornwall
Yes, PORTIS and SPORTIS onboard machines (in use until about 2006) could not encode the magnetic stripe of tickets.
Yes, no strips on the old ticket stock. I'm sure there was rationale around this but I do seem to remember in the late 90s and early 00s that some operators (Know virgin was one) would only use these machines in order to facilitate taking card payments with the train manager writing the actual travel ticket out manually.
Saying that, I'm sure I remember seeing a GNER train manager selling a ticket once in the form of a standard hand written ticket but instead of using a portis machine to swipe the card, he instead took a carbon sheet from his pocket and used a small preserve jam jar in order to trace the card onto the carbon slip.
 

WelshBluebird

Established Member
Joined
14 Jan 2010
Messages
4,923
Guess the guards being able to do it removes it as an excuse for those trying it on! (With them thinking the guard can't print out tickets).
 

island

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Dec 2010
Messages
15,982
Location
0036
Yes, no strips on the old ticket stock. I'm sure there was rationale around this
I imagine when SPORTIS was being specced in the 1990s, the technology to encode magnetic stripe tickets in a portable device was cost-prohibitive, if it even existed at all.
 

Wallsendmag

Established Member
Joined
11 Dec 2014
Messages
5,136
Location
Wallsend or somewhere in GB
I imagine when SPORTIS was being specced in the 1990s, the technology to encode magnetic stripe tickets in a portable device was cost-prohibitive, if it even existed at all.
Try 80s Portis was in use when I transferred to Newcastle in 89 and Sportis came along soon after
 
Last edited:

mmh

Established Member
Joined
13 Aug 2016
Messages
3,744
I imagine when SPORTIS was being specced in the 1990s, the technology to encode magnetic stripe tickets in a portable device was cost-prohibitive, if it even existed at all.

Try TFW's current ticket vending machines. 2021, and they still can't do it. Issue tickets that barriers can't read all the time. Which isn't a problem, unless you're arriving somewhere like Blackpool North with one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top