• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Transdev Blazefield

Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Andyh82

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2014
Messages
3,529
Keighley seem to be struggling a bit with the morning school run out since they went back on Tuesday

They tweeted yesterday that some trips were missed on the 62 & 67 as service buses were pulled from service to be used on schools. Today one of the boards on the 62 has been cancelled until 9:30

Of course, we only know this because they tell us, other operators in the county may also be cancelling runs, we’d just never know.
 

JetBlast

Member
Joined
12 Aug 2010
Messages
218
Location
Australia
Keighley seem to be struggling a bit with the morning school run out since they went back on Tuesday

They tweeted yesterday that some trips were missed on the 62 & 67 as service buses were pulled from service to be used on schools. Today one of the boards on the 62 has been cancelled until 9:30

Of course, we only know this because they tell us, other operators in the county may also be cancelling runs, we’d just never know.

What would the reason for missing these trips please?
 

Andyh82

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2014
Messages
3,529
Aren't there still loads of Rosso ones parked up unused at Blackburn? Why not use them..
Not in the blazefield fleetlist there isn't

Of course it isn't lack of buses, they've got enough buses and some, its the lack of serviceable buses at that very moment

Things seem tight this afternoon as well, with one bus pulled off the 662 to do a school, and the buses doing a round trip and going again quicker than the advertised timetable says they should do

Of course I bet First Bradford are probably dropping some trips now and then as well, just nobody would ever know
 

SCH117X

Established Member
Joined
27 Nov 2015
Messages
1,559
School bus drivers operating designated school to home services (and via versa) are required to have up to date DBS checks whereas normal public service drivers are not, so operators generally could be having staffing issues over additional school services being run
 

markymark2000

On Moderation
Joined
11 May 2015
Messages
3,557
Location
Western Part of the UK
School bus drivers operating designated school to home services (and via versa) are required to have up to date DBS checks whereas normal public service drivers are not, so operators generally could be having staffing issues over additional school services being run
It depends on the area. In some councils it's all H2S buses have to have a DBS driver, in other areas, non DBS drivers can each do 4 trips per month so some companies are rostering drivers in such a way so that they can use non DBS drivers on routes.
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
20,028
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
les. They
That's true but you'll get "cancelled" by some enthusiasts for staying this... ha..

That's not true, in two ways.

Firstly, in respect of Transdev, I don't know if we've actually had confirmation as to what the issue actually is? Is it driver shortage? Or are they struggling to secure additional vehicles? Unless people know the facts, they can't say "bad management" even if it phrased as a loaded question.

Secondly, in respect of people being "cancelled".... well, the only cancelling is done by mods and that's only for a continued infringement of the forum rules. If, however, you are referring to being challenged on the accuracy of posts and your views, surely you're able to back this up with empirical evidence and well argued views?
 

Swimbar

Member
Joined
31 Jan 2018
Messages
377
Location
Wetherby
les. They


That's not true, in two ways.

Firstly, in respect of Transdev, I don't know if we've actually had confirmation as to what the issue actually is? Is it driver shortage? Or are they struggling to secure additional vehicles? Unless people know the facts, they can't say "bad management" even if it phrased as a loaded question.

Secondly, in respect of people being "cancelled".... well, the only cancelling is done by mods and that's only for a continued infringement of the forum rules. If, however, you are referring to being challenged on the accuracy of posts and your views, surely you're able to back this up with empirical evidence and well argued views?
I said 'poor management?' not 'bad management', there is a difference!
I think it reasonable to assume that the master plan for the return to School in September was well prepared.
Transdev Harrogate tweeted a late running service on both Tuesday & Wednesday mornings but no cancellations.
All plans require effective delivery at the 'sharp end'. That is where I was asking is their 'poor management'?
I don't know, hence the question. There must be some reason!
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
20,028
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
I said 'poor management?' not 'bad management', there is a difference!
I think it reasonable to assume that the master plan for the return to School in September was well prepared.
Transdev Harrogate tweeted a late running service on both Tuesday & Wednesday mornings but no cancellations.
All plans require effective delivery at the 'sharp end'. That is where I was asking is their 'poor management'?
I don't know, hence the question. There must be some reason!

Fair point on the misquote - it wasn't intentional and I apologise.

We don't know the circumstances for Transdev behind these cancellations, so questioning the calibre of management seems a strange default. Especially when we all know the massive challenges on ALL operators; the operational and commercial challenges on operators are, to use a Covid buzzword, unprecedented so even the best-laid plans of July were in tatters by August.

What we know is that, within the industry, the challenge in getting sufficient vehicles and drivers to meet these new requirements is incredible. Providing sufficient capacity for socially distanced travel has meant deckers and full-size singles are at a premium. First have been able to reacquire (purchase or loan - not known) some vehicles they had sold but were still awaiting disposal by dealers; others were already promised to new operators. There have been additional closed schools and college workings and that means the additional challenge of getting enough drivers to pilot them. Other firms are amending journeys to make them closed school movements routes, closing them to the general public (with consequent gaps in timetables). These operators, including Transdev, are playing catch up to meet the various government requirements.

It's a fair question to ask why some journeys are being cancelled but given the challenges that all operators are experiencing (and are well documented), a default to suggesting "poor management" as the first port of call seems slightly odd.
 

Swimbar

Member
Joined
31 Jan 2018
Messages
377
Location
Wetherby
Fair point on the misquote - it wasn't intentional and I apologise.

We don't know the circumstances for Transdev behind these cancellations, so questioning the calibre of management seems a strange default. Especially when we all know the massive challenges on ALL operators; the operational and commercial challenges on operators are, to use a Covid buzzword, unprecedented so even the best-laid plans of July were in tatters by August.

What we know is that, within the industry, the challenge in getting sufficient vehicles and drivers to meet these new requirements is incredible. Providing sufficient capacity for socially distanced travel has meant deckers and full-size singles are at a premium. First have been able to reacquire (purchase or loan - not known) some vehicles they had sold but were still awaiting disposal by dealers; others were already promised to new operators. There have been additional closed schools and college workings and that means the additional challenge of getting enough drivers to pilot them. Other firms are amending journeys to make them closed school movements routes, closing them to the general public (with consequent gaps in timetables). These operators, including Transdev, are playing catch up to meet the various government requirements.

It's a fair question to ask why some journeys are being cancelled but given the challenges that all operators are experiencing (and are well documented), a default to suggesting "poor management" as the first port of call seems slightly odd.
I may have become some what cynical in my old age but living within the Transdev operating area and reading frequently on social media posts from them extolling how wonderful they are I do wonder whether there are cracks in the management structure.
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
20,028
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
I may have become some what cynical in my old age but living within the Transdev operating area and reading frequently on social media posts from them extolling how wonderful they are I do wonder whether there are cracks in the management structure.

Alex Hornby is the consummate marketing man, including self-promotion.

However, I neither expect them to make outlandish preposterous claims nor be demurely fanning themselves like a nervous debutante. Yes, it HAS to be more substance than style but in my experience, they are generally one of the better, more positive operators.

Transdev is far from perfect and they are not immune from making mistakes. This may sound a bit like setting a low bar but travel round West Yorkshire and compare Transdev to the functional First and confused Arriva offerings and the difference is telling.
 

philthetube

Established Member
Joined
5 Jan 2016
Messages
3,762
I may have become some what cynical in my old age but living within the Transdev operating area and reading frequently on social media posts from them extolling how wonderful they are I do wonder whether there are cracks in the management structure.
Living in an Arriva area, and occasionally visiting a Transdev one I think they are wonderful.
 

northrob

Member
Joined
18 Feb 2011
Messages
108
Location
York
Alex Hornby is the consummate marketing man, including self-promotion.

However, I neither expect them to make outlandish preposterous claims nor be demurely fanning themselves like a nervous debutante. Yes, it HAS to be more substance than style but in my experience, they are generally one of the better, more positive operators.

Transdev is far from perfect and they are not immune from making mistakes. This may sound a bit like setting a low bar but travel round West Yorkshire and compare Transdev to the functional First and confused Arriva offerings and the difference is telling.

Maybe the people who have an issue with their marketing would be happier if they used #average instead...

Actually, let's take it further. Let's get rid of route branding, fancy route names, passenger features inside the bus or anything else to improve the image of bus travel. From now on all buses everywhere should be just plain white with "BUS" written on the side and Urban 90 seats as standard...

(And just in case you're wondering, I am being sarcastic...)
 

Swimbar

Member
Joined
31 Jan 2018
Messages
377
Location
Wetherby
Would actually be good for the environment. Would dramatically cut down the amount of vynl used by the Harrogate Bus Company!

On a serious note I believe that your average punter only wants the bus to turn up at the correct time and be comfortable.
I don't think they are that bothered how much vynl is stuck on the sides - I accept I am not a marketing expert!
 
Last edited:

northrob

Member
Joined
18 Feb 2011
Messages
108
Location
York
On a serious note I believe that your average punter only wants the bus to turn up at the correct time and be comfortable.
I don't think they are that bothered how much vynl is stuck on the sides - I accept I am not a marketing expert!

And yet, a number of bus companies large and small across the country do it - begs the general question of why do they do it?

Of course, I acknowledge that there's no guarantee of success...
 

Swimbar

Member
Joined
31 Jan 2018
Messages
377
Location
Wetherby
The North Yorkshire County Council Minibus providing some of our local services doesn't need fancy vinyl's to attract passengers. Its take it or leave it!
 

Andyh82

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2014
Messages
3,529
The North Yorkshire County Council Minibus providing some of our local services doesn't need fancy vinyl's to attract passengers. Its take it or leave it!
It doesn’t attract passengers. It will no doubt carry the same ones all the time

Back to the original point and Keighley looks to be running ok now, although the 662 doesn’t seem to be running with as many buses as it should be, with buses stepping up at Keighley end, and occasional missed trips, if bustimes.org is correct.

Keighley has a particularly big school output, operating near enough every school bus in Keighley, Ilkley, Bingley and stretching to Skipton and parts of Bradford
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
20,028
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
Would actually be good for the environment. Would dramatically cut down the amount of vynl used by the Harrogate Bus Company!

On a serious note I believe that your average punter only wants the bus to turn up at the correct time and be comfortable.
I don't think they are that bothered how much vynl is stuck on the sides - I accept I am not a marketing expert!

If marketing doesn't work, why is it such a large industry? Why do firms spend millions when they needn't bother and just have a white box in a supermarket with "Washing Powder" scribbled on in biro?

Indeed, NYCC's welfare minibuses operating off peak between schools are a basic, minimal, passenger unfriendly, take it or leave it, service.

Keighley has a particularly big school output, operating near enough every school bus in Keighley, Ilkley, Bingley and stretching to Skipton and parts of Bradford

I suspect you're right in that Keighley, unlike other depots, has a disproportionately high schools run out and that may be experiencing some capacity issues. However, unless we have a K&D (!) mole, it's just speculation.
 

Top