• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Recent content by HSTEd

  1. HSTEd

    DHELM: Why are UK railways so bad?

    Beyond the myriad organisational issues that people have discussed, the UK is trapped by the oldest railway infrastructure. Tunnels, cuttings and the like built by hand have left us with the smallest standard-gauge loading gauge in the world. Indeed Japanese cape gauge railways typically have...
  2. HSTEd

    it’s a fairly safe bet that standard class passengers and taxpayers will indeed be paying for 1st class refreshments.

    I am no longer convinced that the complication of first class provision on the railway is really justified by the extra income. Personally I wonder if it worsens the issues with the railway by allowing a substantial part of its customer base, an influential portion, to avoid contact with the...
  3. HSTEd

    Where else in the UK could tramways/light rail be installed?

    The vast majority of the traffic on the corridor is contained on the corridor itself or gets dumped a single location in the city centre. A very large fraction of the buses on the corridor run to Piccadilly Gardens as it is. The 8x buses, the 111, the 42/43 and 142/143 buses. Beyond that there...
  4. HSTEd

    Where else in the UK could tramways/light rail be installed?

    Living near the corridor as I do I have spent an awful lot of time considering this problem. It's not an easy problem to solve, which is why personally I tend towards an urban ropeway solution to the Oxford Road challenge. It's only 800m but there is no easy way through, its very tightly...
  5. HSTEd

    Where else in the UK could tramways/light rail be installed?

    That is at the very least debatable. Manchester type tram infrastructure has proven capable of absorbing 30 trams per hour per direction, and using double (or triple) length trams it could swallow up the majority of the Oxford Road traffic comparatively easily. With standing a double tram...
  6. HSTEd

    Clearing the Air - RDG Report

    Perhaps you are right, although I am not entirely convinced given how tone deaf many of their publications are. I have amended the previous post to make it somewhat less strident.
  7. HSTEd

    Clearing the Air - RDG Report

    Well the RDG's position seems to be that noone needs to be convinced of the value of rail and unconditional public and political support is assured. They brush aside complaints by saying that the complainant is wrong and the Railway is clearly amazing in every respect. That leads to production...
  8. HSTEd

    Why did we need HS1?

    Ultimately because the spectacle of a Eurostar rushing across france at 186mph before trundling through Kent was embarassing for the powers that be. By the time HS1 was greenlit the idea of mass travel across the channel by train was dead. It was dying before Eurostar even started, killed by...
  9. HSTEd

    ECML Power Supply Upgrade

    And, in the long term, they may even allow feeder stations to operate in parallel, flattening the load and allowing further increases in utilisation for the overall infrastructure.
  10. HSTEd

    The last coal train?

    Heritage railways would amount to a small number of trainloads per year for the entire country. There is unlikely to be sufficient output in any commercial coal facility to make that market worse serving. Heritage railways are likely to convert to biomass or to oil firing, or stop operating...
  11. HSTEd

    Where else in the UK could tramways/light rail be installed?

    Even there patronage has been falling since about 2014 (even ignoring coronavirus). THere was growth for a few years when the congestion charge briefly reduced traffic in London and allowed increased average speeds, but that effect has now disappeared.
  12. HSTEd

    Where else in the UK could tramways/light rail be installed?

    It might help but it won't save us from the UK obsession with double deckers with a single narrow staircase. I'm not convinced any road based public transport solution can ever be truly attractive to the population.
  13. HSTEd

    Is green electricity subsidising rail freight?

    The problem is we don't have decades to sit around hoping battery electric HGVs with practical operational and economic characteristics will appear. Decarbonisation has to be well under way by 2030, not starting to get started! And what happens if they don't? Waiting to be bailed out by future...
  14. HSTEd

    Is green electricity subsidising rail freight?

    Why? The vast majority of motorways are not constructed in ultra rural environments, and the low load density from allowing lorries to be drawing power for the majority of their operational life will reduce peak demand considerably. A lot of eHighway substations would likely draw power from the...
  15. HSTEd

    Is green electricity subsidising rail freight?

    Well operation of the pantograph system, which is capable of moving around independently of the vehicle, is under the control of an onboard computer rather than the driver. If the driver attempts to leave the lane the system will automatically retract with no further driver action. Maintenance...

Top