Click on 'more options' then next to "Travel via" type in Milton Keynes (MKC) - the London Midland trains stop here whereas most of the Virgin Trains services don't.
That doesn't work, I still get Virgin trains even though Virgin only passes through Milton Keynes and does not stop there.
NRE doesn't sell tickets so if you're using the Virgin Trains website to make the purchase, it will show VT services in preference to LM ones. Try a different site such as
www.eastcoast.co.uk which should show both VT and LM tickets.
That doesn't work either, still no LM trains.
Are you looking for the cheaper London Midland fares?
Yes, looking for cheaper fares.
There are 'London Midland Only' fares for BHM - London, but not for London - Gatwick, the reason being that LM don't serve Gatwick.
That's annoying.
The available fares from BHM - GTW are:
'Any Permitted' (intended to be used on Virgin to London) - £60.10 off-peak return
I travel one way during peak hours, so it is £97.50 for me.
'VIa High Wycombe' (Chiltern to Marylebone) - £42.50 super-off-peak return
That works indeed, £32.00 in my case.
'Via Kensington Olympia' (here you must change at either Milton Keynes or Watford Junction (either Virgin or London Midland are ok), and then take a Southern service to Clapham Junction) £41.30 return
That's £67.90 for me, which is still more expensive than splitting, see below.
In comparison BHM - London super-off-peak return is £23, and Gatwick - London is around £20 for a return, so the via Olympia fare will work out cheaper.
In my case £12.00+£23.70=£35.70.
I would suggest you put travel via Northampton rather than Milton Keynes C.
Wow, that works. That gives £32.00. How come putting Northampton as via station works, while putting Stechford or Milton Keynes does not work?