I only thought it was 2tph?
- 1 tph to Huddersfield via Barnsley and Penistone
- 1 tph to Leeds via Barnsley, Wakefield Kirkgate and Castleford
Which was the third? I didnt think there was a third until the Leeds-Wakefield K - Barnsley - Sheffield - Nottingham service started a few years back?
Midland Mainline (now EMT) used to have an evening service from London StP to Barnsley (via Sheffield) and a morning reverse, but this was removed a number of years ago along with the York extention
It used to be (pre 2004?):
Sheffield - Barnsley - Wakefield - Castleford - Leeds (all stops)
Sheffield - Barnsley - Wakefield (all stops)
Sheffield - Barnsley - Penistone - Huddersfield (all stops)
...each hour. Plus a couple of MML 170s (one of which gave a handy 08.40 arrival into Sheffield)
Then it became
Sheffield - Barnsley - Wakefield - Castleford - Leeds (all stops)
Sheffield - Barnsley - Wakefield Leeds (semi fast)
Sheffield - Barnsley - Penistone - Huddersfield (all stops apart from Elsecar offpeak)
Then it became
Sheffield - Barnsley - Wakefield - Castleford - Leeds (all stops)
Sheffield - Barnsley - Wakefield Leeds (semi fast)
Nottingham - Sheffield - Barnsley - Wakefield Leeds (semi fast)
Sheffield - Barnsley - Penistone - Huddersfield (all stops apart from Elsecar offpeak)
The need to stop at local stations, plus capacity problems between Sheffield and Meadowhall mean I can't see space for a fifth service on the line (unless the Penistone service is replaced by a shuttle to Barnsley, or the Castleford service is replaced by a Leeds - Castleford (Pontefract) service and a Castleford - Wakefield service?
The only other suggestion I have is to use some of the EMT trains from Neville Hill that run "light" to Sheffield in the morning to provide additional capacity from Barnsley to Sheffield (I worked these out on another thread, there are a couple arriving in Sheffield in the morning rush hour)