-
Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!
Doctor Who Series 8
- Thread starter Butts
- Start date
- Status
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R
RailUK Forums
I'm sorry have you used the internet before?
Yeah I'm agreed actually, Capaldi is a nice change from Smith and Tennant who were on the whole, quite similar. The only problem I'm finding is that some of the writing does feel 'left over' from the past series.
There's room for all viewpoints!
I understand some people even liked El Dorado and Triangle (younger members may have to look these up!)
I remember those two.
El Dorado was for people who found Eastenders too intellectually demanding.
Triangle was Crossroads at Sea.
Some of what Capaldi does is good, and I like it. Overall I think he is working against the writes (or vice versa) rather than with them.
--- old post above --- --- new post below ---
Good descriptions!
--- old post above --- --- new post below ---
Good descriptions!
gordonthemoron
Established Member
I agree. I get the impression that they spent the budget on Capaldi's fee and hadn't much left for the scripts
Butts
Veteran Member
Connection between Triangle and Who - an excellent programme featuring Michael Craig and The Rani - aka the late beautiful Kate O'Mara
I agree with the point about Capaldi, and since they were using a 117 anyway it wouldn't be too much extra effort to set up the real one for a shot or two. Oh, and I'm sure that Hornby would be flattered - it had more to do with the pristine condition (re: paintwork, dirt) that the unit was in.
Last edited:
DynamicSpirit
Established Member
There did look something plastic about it at one point. There have been a couple of times during this season when it looked to me like they'd perhaps tried special effects that were beyond their budget to do properly - and the result was a few seconds of something that looked - well - plastic and odd (and reminiscent of 1970s Dr Who). One was this week, with some of the train shots, another was in the Dalek episode, during the scene when lots of Daleks were being destroyed.
I was somewhat surprised because I can't recall any similar badly done special effects from previous post-2004 seasons (and there have been a huge number of very impressive effects), so I'd rather assumed the crew had special effects really well sorted.
Other than that, this week was a good story. I notice the Peter Capaldi Doctor is becoming a lot less reluctant to hide the fact of being an alien from the various random human beings he encountered than previous Doctors were.
Last edited:
He seems to be a lot more arrogant than recent Doctors have been which I suspect is playing a part in him being a bit more laissez-faire about letting people know he's an alien. Also in the Whoverse aren't aliens, not common, but at this point known about to everyone so him being an alien would be shocking but not as shocking as it would be to us?
SpacePhoenix
Established Member
- Joined
- 18 Mar 2014
- Messages
- 5,492
Could it be a side-affect of being on a new set of regenerations?
Strathclyder
Established Member
I think it's a side effect of being in a new regeneration cycle.
I think it's a side effect of being in a new regeneration cycle, Moffat trying to be different AND a general lack of good writing!
I never thought I'd say it, but during this series I've been yearning for a return to the Russell T Davies style of storytelling!
I never thought I'd say it, but during this series I've been yearning for a return to the Russell T Davies style of storytelling!
Perseverance
Member
- Joined
- 11 Jan 2012
- Messages
- 35
Filming of Doctor Who at the Barry Tourist Railway
The 'actual' train running sequences in tunnel were done on the GWR using their Class 117. There were no filmed train movements on our line during filming but our Class 101 'Iris II' featured on the 'feigned' running' close-ups outside and within the driving cab; also the side shots running alongside the DMU 'looking in'. This was all done with the 101 stationary but there were 6 burly lads at the rear of the coach rocking it back and forth to give the impression of movement!
The tunnel scenes with people on the ground were either done in the disused Barry Pier tunnel (where there is no longer any track) or at the BBC studios at Cadriff where we constructed a 30m length of bullhead track within a mocked up tunnel lining and portal built by the skilled BBC scenery people. Shots of this were manipulated to make the tunnel look infinitely longer. All very clever and so realistic that it clearly fooled quite a few people!
And yes…the Tardis appeared between Barry Island Statin and our Plymouth Road shed!
All in all a great project to be involved with - and very beneficial to our railway in many ways.
John Buxton
Director
Barry Tourist Railway
www.barrytouristrailway.co.uk
See us on Facebook too
The 'actual' train running sequences in tunnel were done on the GWR using their Class 117. There were no filmed train movements on our line during filming but our Class 101 'Iris II' featured on the 'feigned' running' close-ups outside and within the driving cab; also the side shots running alongside the DMU 'looking in'. This was all done with the 101 stationary but there were 6 burly lads at the rear of the coach rocking it back and forth to give the impression of movement!
The tunnel scenes with people on the ground were either done in the disused Barry Pier tunnel (where there is no longer any track) or at the BBC studios at Cadriff where we constructed a 30m length of bullhead track within a mocked up tunnel lining and portal built by the skilled BBC scenery people. Shots of this were manipulated to make the tunnel look infinitely longer. All very clever and so realistic that it clearly fooled quite a few people!
And yes…the Tardis appeared between Barry Island Statin and our Plymouth Road shed!
All in all a great project to be involved with - and very beneficial to our railway in many ways.
John Buxton
Director
Barry Tourist Railway
www.barrytouristrailway.co.uk
See us on Facebook too
Last edited:
IanD
Established Member
Accidentally stumbled in to yesterday's episode. Seems the series has become a spin off from The Sarah Jane Adventures much more suited to CBeeBies.
Butts
Veteran Member
We need Cybermen, Daleks, Icemen, Silurians or some form of tangible alien interest - this school association is emasculating the show which is becoming stuck up it's own arse
We need Cybermen, Daleks, Icemen, Silurians or some form of tangible alien interest - this school association is emasculating the show which is becoming stuck up it's own arse
We don't need any more Daleks or Cybermen. We're getting them every series and they're getting boring.
I am somewhat disappointed in this series. As a fan who hasn't missed an episode for over 30 years (though occasionally I've time-shifted one by a few days), last night's episode was the least engaging I've seen in a long time.
All the effort seems to be going into the backstory rather than the individual stories.
I hope it's worth it.
Butts
Veteran Member
[QUOTE=Deerfold;1952947]We don't need any more Daleks or Cybermen. We're getting them every series and they're getting boring.
I am somewhat disappointed in this series. As a fan who hasn't missed an episode for over 30 years (though occasionally I've time-shifted one by a few days), last night's episode was the least engaging I've seen in a long time.
All the effort seems to be going into the backstory rather than the individual stories.
I hope it's worth it.[/QUOTE]
Really ? - I mean a decent run for either - not a cameo appearance.....and bring back "Big D"
I am somewhat disappointed in this series. As a fan who hasn't missed an episode for over 30 years (though occasionally I've time-shifted one by a few days), last night's episode was the least engaging I've seen in a long time.
All the effort seems to be going into the backstory rather than the individual stories.
I hope it's worth it.[/QUOTE]
Really ? - I mean a decent run for either - not a cameo appearance
.....and bring back "Big D"
gordonthemoron
Established Member
bring back the Yeti
Well they've brought back the Great Intelligence. But he's got a bit more sophisticated since then.
Peter Mugridge
Veteran Member
There will be a crisis if that particular enemy materialises in the DfT.....
Tracked
Established Member
Judging by the past few pages I might be going against the grain a bit by saying I've liked series 8 so far, until that episode.
There was a germ of a good idea about humanity facing extinction, but the trees saving the world didn't work, and it could've involved less speaking parts for the children (tree book reader girl in particular, this means you).
Capaldi was good in it though, a bit reminiscent of Eccleston's Doc
There was a germ of a good idea about humanity facing extinction, but the trees saving the world didn't work, and it could've involved less speaking parts for the children (tree book reader girl in particular, this means you).
Capaldi was good in it though, a bit reminiscent of Eccleston's Doc
Well, next time is a cyber-fest with a new twist
The spoiler is that they are upgrading ____ ______ and it might come as a surprise.--- old post above --- --- new post below ---
There is a clue in the official trailer:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETCGtZUn_tU
(Sorry, I couldn't embed)
--- old post above --- --- new post below ---
Oh, and Missy turns out to be ... ......
Last edited:
Somebody who disappeared, without any reason I noticed, and has now re-appeared without explanation. Hopefully these questions will be answered next week.
Hyphen
Member
Did you not notice the MASSIVE GAPING PLOT HOOK at the end of the last related episode?
The ring was going to turn up sooner or later, and she appeared to be wearing it today.
DynamicSpirit
Established Member
I have to admit my reaction to that news was pretty mixed. On the one hand, a sense of 'Oh God, how many times has that character been killed, only to mysteriously reappear later on. Please... not again!' On the other hand, casting as a woman is quite an intriguing idea. And I guess if as you say she's wearing a ring, perhaps that'll make for a reasonable explanation of 'her' re-appearance this time.
Puffing Devil
Established Member
- Joined
- 11 Apr 2013
- Messages
- 2,769
Still not liking this new series. I want real monsters, not Cybermen submerged in water. The current Doctor is better suited to 10pm on BBC Four, not a shoot-em-up slot in prime time.
My kids are losing interest and pay more attention to the Bake Off!
My kids are losing interest and pay more attention to the Bake Off!
IanD
Established Member
Seems I was right, Crapaldi is advertising Dr Who on cbeebies now. That is, some sort of Dr Who spin off on cbeebies.
Last edited:
The series has not improved. I agree that the school and Clara's romance have emasculated the show. The Doctor seems to be a bit of an irrelevance in comparison...perhaps it was intended as a nod to Ian and Barbara 50 years ago, just updated to modern times. If so, it hasn't worked, but I could be hopelessly wrong anyway.
At any rate, Doctor Who should not be a soap!
At any rate, Doctor Who should not be a soap!
- Status