Bantamzen
Established Member
This squad of players is by far the best we've ever had, including the '66 squad in my opinion. We know we have talent all over the pitch, yet for the most part we've seen it only in brief flashes with most of the football being played like we were a National League side playing in the 3rd round of the FA Cup against a top side. The players have looked ill at ease with Southgate's tactics, often finding themselves playing roles not their natural ones to suit Southgate's preferred style. And it only just got us out of the group and through the 2nd Round. Were it not for Bellingham's overhead kick against Slovakia, we'd have been a plane home long before the final.I mean come on how much more does he have to do to allow you to show a bit of objectivity? Did you hold Cappello or Erikson to the same standards? What about Hodgson? Keegan? Taylor? Maclaren? Hoddle? Venables lost a Euro semi does he get your ire? Robson lost a world cup semi. Awful?
Just to be clear on Southgate:
2018 World Cup – 4th place
Euro 2020 – Runners up
2022 World Cup – Quarter-final
Euro 2024 – Runners up
63% win rate
He will do for me - who do you want instead?
EDIT - I will add this, because, you know, you have to state the obvious: Southgate is not a fantastic manager. He is a good manager who has done a good if unspectacular job of just chugging away and progressing in tournaments. He has been to slow to make substitutes, to slow to respond to changes in the game and is a cautious manager who doesn't take many risks. He is a good guy, all the players say positive things about him. He has improved the atmosphere around and within the England team and is always willing to take on the criticism to shield the players. He also seems to be a good modern leader with sensible honest values.
The big what if for me is the Italy game at Wembley. That was the one we should have won.
So watching a team under-perform so much is disappointing, because never mind the Italy game, this was the tournament that we could have won. But instead we, as you put it, chugged our way through and eventually the tactics failed at the crucial point, made all the worse because we should have built momentum after Palmer's goal but instead withdrew and invited Spain to have another go, which they duly did. There is even a story on the BBC site today headlined "England have the best squad, but not the best team", which is exactly how I see it. And under Southgate I don't see this changing, in fact we risk becoming so predicable that qualification could become trickier let alone getting to a final again.
And who would I like to take over? It's never going to happen in a million years, but Jurgen Klopp. I think he would be exactly what the England squad from an OK team of chuggers into a team not only capable of finally getting a trophy, but playing well getting there.