• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

London Euston or Watford Jn to Manchester?

Status
Not open for further replies.

BluePenguin

On Moderation
Joined
26 Sep 2016
Messages
1,605
Location
Kent
I am travelling up to see a friend next week. I am planning to travel on Thursday 10th or Friday 11th of February. Time is not an issue although evening is preferable. I would likely come back on the Sunday or Monday. I will probably start from Euston. However I may visit Grandparents the night before and travel from Watford Junction instead. It seems that Avanti charge more to go to Manchester than they do Liverpool. Splitting up the likes of Tamworth and Litchfield does little to decrease the price. It doesn’t help that not many Manchester services are running via Crewe at the moment.


There seems to be a few cheap advances priced around £25 although I am wondering if any thing might be available cheaper than that? As a last resort I will buy a super off-peak return valid on Northwestern and TFW only. However a Pendolino would be nice. Thanks in advance!
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

JonathanH

Veteran Member
Joined
29 May 2011
Messages
18,903
There seems to be a few cheap advances priced around £25 although I am wondering if any thing might be available cheaper than that?
Pretty much the going rate now for the cheapest journeys over that sort of distance.
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
11,917
The £35 Super Off Peak Return (Route WMR/LNR/TfW only) is likely to be your cheapest walk up ticket from London Euston to Manchester Piccadilly, but is quite restrictive as regards times and the ToCs you can use. So not Avanti, Northern or XC. See link below.


Not sure if there is an equivalent ticket starting from Watford Junction.
 

robbeech

Established Member
Joined
11 Nov 2015
Messages
4,678
I haven’t looked so these combinations may be no use whatsoever but I’m aware of a few cheap advances that may line up quite well.

Look at going via Sheffield, split advances St Pancras to Sheffield and A Northern advance Sheffield to Manchester.

Chiltern Marylebone to Moor Street are sometimes a fiver without a railcard. If you can match that with a good one to Manchester.

Probably won’t beat the wmr/lnr/TfW super off peak fare in total but may get a bit more suitable timings.
 

yorkie

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Administrator
Joined
6 Jun 2005
Messages
67,930
Location
Yorkshire
I am travelling up to see a friend next week. I am planning to travel on Thursday 10th or Friday 11th of February. Time is not an issue although evening is preferable. I would likely come back on the Sunday or Monday. I will probably start from Euston. However I may visit Grandparents the night before and travel from Watford Junction instead. It seems that Avanti charge more to go to Manchester than they do Liverpool. Splitting up the likes of Tamworth and Litchfield does little to decrease the price. It doesn’t help that not many Manchester services are running via Crewe at the moment.


There seems to be a few cheap advances priced around £25 although I am wondering if any thing might be available cheaper than that? As a last resort I will buy a super off-peak return valid on Northwestern and TFW only. However a Pendolino would be nice. Thanks in advance!
Have you tried Trainsplit?

If you don't mind a slow journey, Trainsplit in value mode should find whatever is cheapest out of the combined West Midlands Trains (LNR/WMR brands) & TfW tickets, or a combination of tickets.
 

TT-ONR-NRN

Established Member
Joined
30 Dec 2016
Messages
10,508
Location
Farnham
£25 is quite good for London to Manchester on Avanti, is it not? They often charge me far more and that's with a 16-25 Railcard.
 

JonathanH

Veteran Member
Joined
29 May 2011
Messages
18,903
Chiltern Marylebone to Moor Street are sometimes a fiver without a railcard. If you can match that with a good one to Manchester.
Lowest tier on Chiltern from London to Birmingham is now £6.40, with not much availability. More typically in the £10 - £16 range now.
 
Last edited:

Kite159

Veteran Member
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
19,289
Location
West of Andover
The £35 Super Off Peak Return (Route WMR/LNR/TfW only) is likely to be your cheapest walk up ticket from London Euston to Manchester Piccadilly, but is quite restrictive as regards times and the ToCs you can use. So not Avanti, Northern or XC. See link below.


Not sure if there is an equivalent ticket starting from Watford Junction.

The £45 "Off-peak return" version has a lot less restrictions in terms of timings (no afternoon restrictions, only morning). Although that ticket seems to be only London Euston to Manchester, doesn't exist if you start from Watford (or end at Stockport), but I can't see any "break of journey" restrictions like on the Super Off-peak ticket [so the OP could purchase a London - Manchester ticket and start short at Watford)

Just beware they can be a bit awkward to purchase due to the longer journey times, especially if you come back on a Sunday from Manchester as the Manchester - South Wales train isn't an official connection to the Crewe - London train [but as most of the Manchester - South Wales use P6 and most of the Crewe - London trains use P7 it's an easy enough connection unless the train is late
 

yorkie

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Administrator
Joined
6 Jun 2005
Messages
67,930
Location
Yorkshire
P5 I think!
You are thinking of the Liverpool/Glasgow/Edinburgh/Blackpool - London Avanti services which call at Crewe, but the poster above was talking about using tickets only valid on West Midlands Trains (LNR/WMR brands) between Crewe & London, which are the Crewe - London services starting at (bay) Platform 7.
 

erk

Member
Joined
21 Nov 2012
Messages
117
The Route WMR/LNR/TfW only tickets are normally good value, but currently TfW are terminating many S Wales - Manchester trains at Crewe. That means the ticket often won't cover the Crewe - Manchester leg, or not without a long wait or an extra ticket. Northern advances can be cheap, but the trains are even slower!
 

BluePenguin

On Moderation
Joined
26 Sep 2016
Messages
1,605
Location
Kent
Pretty much the going rate now for the cheapest journeys over that sort of distance.
It is a shame isn't it? Once upon a time I could get a £20 advance from Deal to Liverpool

From?
London?
Yes, as I already have a ticket from Kent

The £35 Super Off Peak Return (Route WMR/LNR/TfW only) is likely to be your cheapest walk up ticket from London Euston to Manchester Piccadilly, but is quite restrictive as regards times and the ToCs you can use. So not Avanti, Northern or XC. See link below.


Not sure if there is an equivalent ticket starting from Watford Junction.
It is certainly the cheapest although very very limiting! I suppose I could easily double back through Euston if I needed to

I haven’t looked so these combinations may be no use whatsoever but I’m aware of a few cheap advances that may line up quite well.

Look at going via Sheffield, split advances St Pancras to Sheffield and A Northern advance Sheffield to Manchester.

Chiltern Marylebone to Moor Street are sometimes a fiver without a railcard. If you can match that with a good one to Manchester.

Probably won’t beat the wmr/lnr/TfW super off peak fare in total but may get a bit more suitable timings.
I did take a look at going from St Pancras to Sheffield although strangely this came out as more expensive. I have wanted to have a ride of the Hope Valley line though so it is a contender.

Have you tried Trainsplit?

If you don't mind a slow journey, Trainsplit in value mode should find whatever is cheapest out of the combined West Midlands Trains (LNR/WMR brands) & TfW tickets, or a combination of tickets.
Yes, sadly it didn't produce many other alternatives.

£25 is quite good for London to Manchester on Avanti, is it not? They often charge me far more and that's with a 16-25 Railcard.
In the current circumstances it would seem that £25 is good value. Although Liverpool is a similar distance yet is only £15 and £13 at around the same times. I also will have to book a return leg. I suppose time is money and that this is the market price. Tickets are no cheaper even 3 weeks later

Lowest tier on Chiltern from London to Birmingham is now £6.40, with not much availability. More typically in the £10 - £16 range now.
Now that does sound appealing, I hadn't considered looking at Chiltern - thank you!

The £45 "Off-peak return" version has a lot less restrictions in terms of timings (no afternoon restrictions, only morning). Although that ticket seems to be only London Euston to Manchester, doesn't exist if you start from Watford (or end at Stockport), but I can't see any "break of journey" restrictions like on the Super Off-peak ticket [so the OP could purchase a London - Manchester ticket and start short at Watford)

Just beware they can be a bit awkward to purchase due to the longer journey times, especially if you come back on a Sunday from Manchester as the Manchester - South Wales train isn't an official connection to the Crewe - London train [but as most of the Manchester - South Wales use P6 and most of the Crewe - London trains use P7 it's an easy enough connection unless the train is late
The long journey times are a pain. I have made the 3 minute connection at Stafford a few times before when heading to Liverpool. From Kent the end to end journey time is around 5 hours, not great although fine when on a budget.

You are thinking of the Liverpool/Glasgow/Edinburgh/Blackpool - London Avanti services which call at Crewe, but the poster above was talking about using tickets only valid on West Midlands Trains (LNR/WMR brands) between Crewe & London, which are the Crewe - London services starting at (bay) Platform 7.
That is correct. If only LNR ran directly to Manchester and Liverpool on through trains, maybe one day eh?

The Route WMR/LNR/TfW only tickets are normally good value, but currently TfW are terminating many S Wales - Manchester trains at Crewe. That means the ticket often won't cover the Crewe - Manchester leg, or not without a long wait or an extra ticket. Northern advances can be cheap, but the trains are even slower!
Ironically, paying for an extra ticket to travel to Manchester on Avanti from Crewe does save time.
 

jfollows

Established Member
Joined
26 Feb 2011
Messages
5,858
Location
Wilmslow
You are thinking of the Liverpool/Glasgow/Edinburgh/Blackpool - London Avanti services which call at Crewe, but the poster above was talking about using tickets only valid on West Midlands Trains (LNR/WMR brands) between Crewe & London, which are the Crewe - London services starting at (bay) Platform 7.
Thank you, I was, and you're right.
 

BluePenguin

On Moderation
Joined
26 Sep 2016
Messages
1,605
Location
Kent
Let’s keep this thread alive, price is not everything. I still have not come to a conclusion. Out of the routes mentioned above which is the most preferable and why? Opinions please. Honest reviews may help to positively sway my decision

So far @TT-ONR-NRN says £25 in their opinion is good value for London - Manchester. Although in comparison to what?

For example, for the return journey buying an advance at the same price would equal £50. At this stage, a railcard holder would be looking at a similar price to an off-peak return.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top