• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

No Eurostar to Amsterdam for almost a year

philg999

Member
Joined
20 Apr 2021
Messages
105
Location
Amsterdam
Just noticed this on a Dutch national broadcaster news page. No Eurostar from Amsterdam for 1 year after May 2024 :( https://nos.nl/artikel/2477477-volgend-jaar-maandenlang-geen-eurostar-vanuit-amsterdam-naar-londen
From June 2024, no trains will run from Amsterdam to London for months. This is due to large-scale work on Amsterdam Central station, State Secretary Heijnen of Infrastructure reports to the House of Representatives.

Due to the work, there is no room for the customs post at Amsterdam Central Station.

It is still being investigated whether the Eurostar trains can run directly from London to Amsterdam, and the consequences for travellers who want to travel from Rotterdam to London by Eurostar are also being examined
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

hexagon789

Veteran Member
Joined
2 Sep 2016
Messages
15,839
Location
Glasgow
I thought it was just being diverted so it wouldn't run into Centraal but another Amsterdam station temporarily?

Has that changed or have I picked it up wrong?
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,496
Location
Bristol
See this older thread: https://www.railforums.co.uk/thread...ded-until-2028-is-this-just-clickbait.232915/
I thought it was just being diverted so it wouldn't run into Centraal but another Amsterdam station temporarily?

Has that changed or have I picked it up wrong?
AIUI the plan was for Amsterdam-Zuid (South) to be rebuilt to have a permanent base for Eurostar, then move Eurostar over to allow the Amsterdam Centraal rebuild to start. However the Zuid rebuild is overrunning and the Centraal rebuild needs to start to avoid delaying other service changes planned for NS.
It sounds like various proposals including using other platforms at Centraal have been unable to work, and the suggestion of that NOS article is that Eurostar will revert to terminating at Brussels as Rotterdam is not able to serve the Amsterdam demand on it's own (if I've read it right, my dutch is non-existent so I've read the Google translate). It's not clear if after 1 year Eurostar would go back to Centraal or just use Zuid.
 

paul1609

Established Member
Joined
28 Jan 2006
Messages
7,269
Location
Wittersham Kent
What sort of loadings do the Amsterdam trains enjoy after Brussels? Cant help but think the trains are on their way to more profitable routes within the Eurostar (Thalys) network and Amsterdam and Rotterdam are about to join the network of ex Eurostar stations that may be served again some time in the future.
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,496
Location
Bristol
What sort of loadings do the Amsterdam trains enjoy after Brussels? Cant help but think the trains are on their way to more profitable routes within the Eurostar (Thalys) network and Amsterdam and Rotterdam are about to join the network of ex Eurostar stations that may be served again some time in the future.
AIUI from the explanation of the passport issues, Amsterdam and Rotterdam sell all the available tickets but the limited size of the departure lounges mean they restricted how many the sell. However Eurostar have explicitly said they'd like to add an extra train per day to Amsterdam in the near term, and in the medium term even drop the Brussels stops out of the Netherlands services.
 

DanielB

Member
Joined
27 Feb 2020
Messages
969
Location
Amersfoort, NL
AIUI the plan was for Amsterdam-Zuid (South) to be rebuilt to have a permanent base for Eurostar, then move Eurostar over to allow the Amsterdam Centraal rebuild to start. However the Zuid rebuild is overrunning and the Centraal rebuild needs to start to avoid delaying other service changes planned for NS.
According to the letter of state secretary Ms. Heijnen (responsible for public transport at the ministry for infrastructure and water management) to the parliament, they managed to extend the use of the current terminal to June 2024 already. Further extension was not possible for safety reasons, as at July 1st platforms 14 and 15 at Amsterdam Central are taken out of service due to works to replace the bridge crossing the Oostertoegang canal located immediately behind the terminal. (See Google Streetview with the respective bridge on the left and the terminal on the right)
Target date to complete the new Eurostar terminal in the Amstelpassage is planned for spring 2025, but they are planning to speed up construction of this terminal. In the most optimistic scenario it would be ready for use in January 2025 already. Constructing a temporary facility to bridge the gap was found not to be feasible as it would take longer than construction of the new Amstelpassage terminal.
In the optimistic scenario there would still be an accessibility issue as from January till April 2025 the platform would only be accessible from the terminal using stairs. Lifts and escalators wouldn't be available during that period.

The new Amsterdam Zuid terminal, combined with an additional platform at that station, would take until 2036 to be completed. So that's not really an alternative.
 
Last edited:

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,496
Location
Bristol
According to the letter of state secretary Ms. Heijnen (responsible for public transport at the ministry for infrastructure and water management) to the parliament, they managed to extend the use of the current terminal to June 2024 already. Further extension was not possible for safety reasons, as at July 1st platforms 14 and 15 at Amsterdam Central are taken out of service due to works to replace the bridge crossing the Oostertoegang canal located immediately behind the terminal.
Target date to complete the new Eurostar terminal in the Amstelpassage is planned for spring 2025, but they are planning to speed up construction of this terminal. In the most optimistic scenario it would be ready for use in January 2025 already. Constructing a temporary facility to bridge the gap was found not to be feasible as it would take longer than construction of the new Amstelpassage terminal.
In the optimistic scenario there would still be an accessibility issue as from January till April 2025 the platform would only be accessible from the terminal using stairs. Lifts and escalators wouldn't be available during that period.

The new Amsterdam Zuid terminal, combined with an additional platform at that station, would take until 2036 to be completed. So that's not really an alternative.
For clarity (I'm not very familiar with Amsterdam), is the Amstelpassage terminal still at Centraal, and would this be a permanent terminal to complement Zuid in some way?

Many thanks for the info.
 

30907

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Sep 2012
Messages
18,166
Location
Airedale
Article suggests an alternative hasn't been found and ES don't want to stop short at Rotterdam (which in any case probably couldn't cope with the passenger load)
For clarity (I'm not very familiar with Amsterdam), is the Amstelpassage terminal still at Centraal
Yes
and would this be a permanent terminal to complement Zuid in some way?
Doubt it.
 

DanielB

Member
Joined
27 Feb 2020
Messages
969
Location
Amersfoort, NL
For clarity (I'm not very familiar with Amsterdam), is the Amstelpassage terminal still at Centraal, and would this be a permanent terminal to complement Zuid in some way?
Yes, the Amstelpassage is one of the two tunnels constructed underneath the platforms several years ago to allow pedestrians to pass through the station without having to use an OV-chipkaart to pass trough the ticket barriers. It currently has already closed due to renovation works in the eastern wing of the station building and would be less needed for capacity in the future as the easternmost passage under the platforms is currently also being widened.
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,496
Location
Bristol
Yes, the Amstelpassage is one of the two tunnels constructed underneath the platforms several years ago to allow pedestrians to pass through the station without having to use an OV-chipkaart to pass trough the ticket barriers. It currently has already closed due to renovation works in the eastern wing of the station building and would be less needed for capacity in the future as the easternmost passage under the platforms is currently also being widened.
Thanks (and to @30907).
 

popeter45

Member
Joined
7 Dec 2019
Messages
1,113
Location
london
Thinking out loud here but was any consideration made to something like a movable temp terminal?, Get some old NS, SNCF or DB carriages, kit one or two out as security and passport checks and station it somewhere like platform 1, able to move it out of the way when not needed or as platforms open/close thru the renovations?

Also any possibility of a "Brussels shuffle"? Using the same 374 for Brussels to London as Amsterdam to Brussels?
 
Last edited:

AdamWW

Established Member
Joined
6 Nov 2012
Messages
3,710
In the optimistic scenario there would still be an accessibility issue as from January till April 2025 the platform would only be accessible from the terminal using stairs. Lifts and escalators wouldn't be available during that period.

While not at all ideal presumably Rotterdam would still be available for passengers needing lifts/escalators. and could perhaps cope with the extra demand in a way that it couldn't if attempting to accommodate all passengers who would otherwise have used Amsterdam.
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,496
Location
Bristol
Thinking out loud here but was any consideration made to something like a movable temp terminal?, Get some old NS, SNCF or DB carriages, kit one or two out as security and passport checks and station it somewhere like platform 1, able to move it out of the way when not needed or as platforms open/close thru the renovations?
This would require 2 sides of an island, if you're expecting everybody to essentially board a waiting train until the Eurostar is ready for departure.
Also any possibility of a "Brussels shuffle"? Using the same 374 for Brussels to London as Amsterdam to Brussels?
While not at all ideal presumably Rotterdam would still be available for passengers needing lifts/escalators. and could perhaps cope with the extra demand in a way that it couldn't if attempting to accommodate all passengers who would otherwise have used Amsterdam.
By far the easier option for passengers is to sell them tickets using a Thalys train from Amsterdam to Brussels and advise passengers to board Eurostar there. I can't see Rotterdam staying viable if the Eurostar isn't able to continue to Amsterdam with passengers on board.
 

popeter45

Member
Joined
7 Dec 2019
Messages
1,113
Location
london
Yea that's what I was suggesting with my second part, Just using the spare 374s from the outwards journey as a additional Amsterdam to Brussels thalys during its repositioning
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,496
Location
Bristol
Yea that's what I was suggesting with my second part, Just using the spare 374s from the outwards journey as a additional Amsterdam to Brussels thalys during its repositioning
Quite possible - IIRC that's what they did before the Amsterdam terminal was ready, carrying London-Amsterdam passengers through but sending Amsterdam-London passengers on a Thalys to Brussels. It depends on the platform capacity at Centraal, as the departure terminal isn't the only problem when they're rebuilding the station, they'll be taking tracks out of use as well.
 

DanielB

Member
Joined
27 Feb 2020
Messages
969
Location
Amersfoort, NL
It depends on the platform capacity at Centraal, as the departure terminal isn't the only problem when they're rebuilding the station, they'll be taking tracks out of use as well.
Looking at the track maps of Amsterdam Central and surrounding yards, part of the challenge is in the replacement of the bridges east of the station. In the period the Amsterdam terminal is unavailable bridge 3 on this map (right hand side in tracks 74 and 75 is being replaced. Following those tracks towards Watergraafsmeer yard (Wgm at the map) it quickly becomes clear that a Eurostar can't get from the international cleaning platforms (C3, C4, C5 and C6) to Amsterdam Central during that period.
For most trains that's not really a problem as the new Westhaven yard on the west side of the station has recently opened, which for example is where the Nightjets get their cleaning now. But Eurostar has a ban on reversing within the Netherlands as this results in the secure side being at the wrong side in Brussels.
 

LLivery

Established Member
Joined
13 Jul 2014
Messages
1,466
Location
London
Crazy idea - no idea if it'd work, but would it be possible to have a Eurostar set do London > Amsterdam > Paris > London?

So London - Amsterdam as normal. Then runs a Thalys service to Paris (people change at Brussels for London) and then from Paris, it runs a Eurostar service back to London. Probably a mere to work out, but it'd be something and keeps a direct train between London and Dam in one direction at least.
 

richa2002

Established Member
Joined
8 Jun 2005
Messages
2,277
Crazy idea - no idea if it'd work, but would it be possible to have a Eurostar set do London > Amsterdam > Paris > London?

So London - Amsterdam as normal. Then runs a Thalys service to Paris (people change at Brussels for London) and then from Paris, it runs a Eurostar service back to London. Probably a mere to work out, but it'd be something and keeps a direct train between London and Dam in one direction at least.
Seems like a lot of hassle when it could just run ECS back to Brussels instead and form a service from there.
 

StephenHunter

Established Member
Joined
22 Jul 2017
Messages
2,158
Location
London
By far the easier option for passengers is to sell them tickets using a Thalys train from Amsterdam to Brussels and advise passengers to board Eurostar there. I can't see Rotterdam staying viable if the Eurostar isn't able to continue to Amsterdam with passengers on board.

They're all Eurostar now, aren't they?
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,496
Location
Bristol
They're all Eurostar now, aren't they?
They may be branded as such but the two operations are still fairly separate as the merger takes effect. The PBA/PBKA stock doesn't go to London (I'm fairly sure it isn't certified in the Tunnel) and the 373/374 fleet doesn't run intra-schengen services (for the moment, it could change).
Hasn’t stopped them at St Pancras!
St Pancras has a problem handling the busiest peak loading but is OK for the majority of the day. Eurostar restrict ticket sales at peak times to manage the St Pancras loadings. Amsterdam physically can't hold more than a couple of hundred, much less than the capacity of the 374 (c.900), at any time of day.
 

island

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Dec 2010
Messages
16,209
Location
0036
Seems like a lot of hassle when it could just run ECS back to Brussels instead and form a service from there.
Need not be ECS; before the passports/security facilities were commissioned at Amsterdam Centraal and Rotterdam Centraal, Eurostar used to run in revenue service from Amsterdam Centraal to Brussel Zuid, arriving in platform 1 or 2 where everyone was turfed out. The train would then form a Bruxelles-Midi to London service around 45 minutes later. The quick and the confident could book separate tickets for the two legs and run around to go through formalities and re-board the same train!

Hasn’t stopped them at St Pancras!
It has, actually. Morning departures from St. Pancras are limited to around 600 passengers.
 

HSTEd

Veteran Member
Joined
14 Jul 2011
Messages
16,800
But Eurostar has a ban on reversing within the Netherlands as this results in the secure side being at the wrong side in Brussels.
Could you quickily clarify what you mean by this?

Is one side of the train kept locked at all times or something similar?
 

island

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Dec 2010
Messages
16,209
Location
0036
If I am not mistaken, only the seats in pme half of a Eurostar service from the Netherlands are sold for onward travel to London. This is the "secure half" of the train.

It used to be the case that the other half was for Netherlands to Brussels passengers and the last coach for Netherlands/Brussels to Lille passengers, who would not be required to go through passport checks (or security?) and would be assiduously shooed off the train at the relevant location.

The train on arriving at platform 3 in Bruxelles-Midi would then have to be the right way around in order for everyone not cleared for London to be detrained into the right place.

Now I am not sure that Eurostar still sells intra-Schengen journeys any more so this process may have changed.

Some or all of this may be mistaken so if someone else says something different, they're probably right.
 
Last edited:

DanielB

Member
Joined
27 Feb 2020
Messages
969
Location
Amersfoort, NL
Is one side of the train kept locked at all times or something similar?
Yes, departing from Amsterdam the front half of the train is not security swept and kept locked. The rear part is security swept and stops along the platform half that's also cleared by security and only accessible for checked-in Eurostar passengers.

Security is really tight: we've recently had a situation with track works at Rotterdam Central and domestic IC-services using track number 2 (where the Eurostar facility is). The ICs passing Rotterdam within 30 minutes prior to a Eurostar actually had to run empty after The Hague as not even a non-stop train with passengers was allowed to pass by during those 30 minutes.

Now I am not sure that Eurostar still sells intra-Schengen journeys any more so this process may have changed.
Intra-Schengen tickets are no longer sold to allow for a shorter stop in Brussels. But the trains still need to be the right way round in Brussels to ensure passengers from the Brussels terminal can enter the empty part of the train.

This has already led to cancellations in the recent past during track works that didn't allow for a westbound departure from Amsterdam. Eurostars actually are only being diverted via Leiden after Schiphol, or from Amsterdam via Haarlem. They've never used the diversion via Breukelen - Woerden to get to Rotterdam (or even via Utrecht to Breda), which are commonly used by Thalys, but results in a secure part at the front instead of the rear of the train in Brussels.
 

Gaelan

Member
Joined
3 Apr 2023
Messages
814
Location
St Andrews
If I am not mistaken, only the seats in the front half of a Eurostar service from the Netherlands are sold for onward travel to London. This is the "secure half" of the train.

It used to be the case that the rear half was for Netherlands to Brussels passengers and the last coach for Netherlands/Brussels to Lille passengers, who would not be required to go through passport checks (or security?) and would be assiduously shooed off the train at the relevant location.

The train on arriving at platform 3 in Bruxelles-Midi would then have to be the right way around in order for everyone not cleared for London to be detrained into the right place.

Now I am not sure that Eurostar still sells intra-Schengen journeys any more so this process may have changed.

Some or all of this may be mistaken so if someone else says something different, they're probably right.
For what it’s worth, I was on an Amsterdam to London Eurostar a few weeks ago. At Amsterdam CS, the “secure area” is delineated by a movable barrier on the platform that’s put into place once all passengers are in the departure lounge; this barrier is half way long the train, so only the back carriages are in the secure area, while the front carriages are locked out of use. The same back carriages are boarded at Rotterdam (where the barrier between the secure and non-secure areas is a permanent glass wall). Presumably the front carriages are used for Brussels-London passengers.

(Incidentally, my Eurostar was diverted via Haarlem due to a points failure - assume that didn’t change anything.)
 

BahrainLad

Member
Joined
3 Aug 2015
Messages
314
Do the Amsterdam - London Eurostars actually carry "domestic" passengers to Brussels in the front portion, as originally proposed, or do they just run empty?
 

island

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Dec 2010
Messages
16,209
Location
0036
Do the Amsterdam - London Eurostars actually carry "domestic" passengers to Brussels in the front portion, as originally proposed, or do they just run empty?
As mentioned up-thread, they run empty.
 

Austriantrain

Established Member
Joined
13 Aug 2018
Messages
1,325
As mentioned up-thread, they run empty.

I am perfectly aware of the reasons for it and know that it can’t change - but, what an utter waste. And no surprise that E* struggles with offering cheaper tickets.
 

Top