That's a great trip and fabulous to include a walk. I have never managed a 10 mile walk, 2-3 miles is the most I would want to do on a bus trip but that sounds delightful. Sorry to hear your experience of 'flexible' bus services, I don't think what you encountered is that uncommon although others have few passengers. The only time I have done this was some years ago, from Saltfleet to Mablethorpe in Lincolnshire, and I booked this by phone the day before. Pleasing to hear the 73 was busy, this used to be half-hourly until Covid struck and is still normally hourly so hopefully demand remains. I do worry that the remaining routes in this area will all vanish in the face of the unpredictable options like YorBus.Yesterday was finally a decent chance for me to get out and about - a gap in my university classes coinciding with a day of reasonably decent weather. So I decided to make the most of it and explore an area I've rarely visited before - in the heart of North Yorkshire. It wasn't really a trip centred on buses (I expected the main part to be a 10 mile walk), and I certainly didn't expect there to be much material for a report... but there were quite a few surprises and mishaps which I thought deserved a little write up.
To start with, I headed into Gateshead and boarded the X10 service to head south. This flagship route, connecting Tyneside and Teesside, was operated using coaches the last time I used it, but last month the decision was made to revert back to double deckers, taken from the X84 and X85 routes. As with all of the X Lines routes, the buses are to a very high specification, and the change doesn't feel like much of a downgrade. Being in the morning peak, the service was fairly busy, with a fairly even split between passengers making end-to-end journeys and those using travelling to or from intermediate destinations like Dalton Park or Peterlee. And even though the route now serves all stops (no longer alternating between skipping Dalton Park/Billingham and Peterlee/Stockton), it still feels very fast - particularly the section between Peterlee and Billingham.
I decided to get off the bus at Stockton, giving me time to stretch my legs, get a coffee, and walk to Thornaby, where I boarded the direct train to Thirsk. I then walked from Thirsk station to Ripon - that's the ten mile walk I mentioned at the start of the post. I won't dwell on it because it's outwith the scope of this thread, but needless to say it was a very enjoyable saunter through some lovely country in the Vale of York. Crucially though, I made good time, arriving at Ripon fully half an hour earlier than planned.
This was where the fun began. Frequencies in this part of North Yorkshire are pretty poor, and in particular the timings on the 70 which runs from Ripon to Thirsk station (and Northallerton) are unhelpful, with no departures between 13:40 and 17:35 (presumably the bus which operates on the 70 does a school run around this time). However, I was aware that North Yorkshire were trialling a DRT scheme called YorBus in the area to the north of the city, and Bedale and Northallerton were connected by a relatively frequent service, so I had planned to use YorBus to Bedale and then head to Northallerton station. While booking the service in advance was not possible, I felt confident that this plan would work: in the days before my trip I'd used the app as if I were making a booking, to see the options which were presented. And they always seemed reasonable - typically involving about 30 minutes waiting in Ripon and then about 30 minutes travelling to Bedale - though of course I never actually booked them.
As soon as I arrived at Ripon, I opened the app and tried to book a journey... and the two options involved a 52 or 48 minute wait. I wasn't too upset - I was ahead of schedule, and I'd planned to spend the wait looking around the centre anyway - but it certainly made me nervous. About a quarter of an hour before the initial planned pick up time, I walked to the bus station, and checked the app again to be promptly told the bus had been delayed and it was now due in 20 minutes. Before long, it became clear that even this revised estimate was too optimistic, with the bus spending several minutes at the same location in the outskirts of Ripon - perhaps a passenger was booked to board the bus there, but didn't turn up? Whatever the reason, I felt increasingly concerned, but the YorBus finally arrived just as I was about to make contingency plans. It turned up at 15:50 - fifteen minutes later than I initially expected and nearly seventy minutes later than I had made my booking. Still, provided we made decent time, I would easily make my 16:35 connection at Bedale... right?
Wrong. The flexible aspect of the service, where the route can vary dramatically depending on demand, put paid to that. The bus headed almost all the way to the westernmost point of the zone, making a drop off near Masham, before heading east towards Bedale. The driver certainly did his best along the narrow country lanes, but we arrived at Bedale at 16:38 - by which time the bus I planned to get had left. I made good use of the hour and a half in Bedale, having dinner and a couple of pints at a very nice pub in town, but it did force me to change my plans and I had to book a train north from Northallerton. I could have returned the way I had came, but it would have meant long waits at Northallerton and Middlesbrough, and a very late arrival back into Gateshead!
By the time I was on the 73 from Bedale to Northallerton, it was completely dark outside. I was surprised at how busy the bus was - and almost all fare paying passengers. The fare was £3.05: a very awkward sum considering Dales and District only accept cash. Fortunately I'd checked the price beforehand using the government's open fare data (which is now surprisingly comprehensive), but I imagine drivers have to give 95p in change quite often. The service dropped me right at Northallerton station, which was very convenient for me to catch my train home.
So overall, it was a much more eventful day than planned. In hindsight, I was probably wrong to trust YorBus as much as I did - even with quite a wide margin for error, DRT services just aren't predictable. There's also the issue of financial sustainability - I only paid £1.20 for my single which is a great bargain, but that means breaking even would require huge numbers of passengers. While YorBus was much busier than other DRT services I've used in the past or read reports of, it's still hard to see how it can cover its costs. On a brighter note, it was good to see decent loadings on all of the services I used today - hopefully this is sign passengers are returning to normal!
As the weather wasn't looking too pretty out West I heading East to cobble up a day out. This time East to Sussex.
The day started early with a Southern service to Brighton. At Worthing I quickly changed trains to a diverted Gatwick Express branded 387 that would get me to Brighton quicker, I had a short connection at Brighton.
At Brighton I took the next Southern service to Hastings. At £11.55 return a Southampton to Hastings off peak day return with railcard discount is great value. The line beyond Lewes was new for me, so new line bonus!
From Hastings my rough idea was work back towards Brighton by bus. I had no concrete plans after that. I had a discovery ticket.
Stagecoach 99 Hastings to Eastbourne E300
A 58 plate E300 showed up for the 99 to Eastbourne, one of them uncomfortable ones with low back seats, it seemed every other 99 was a decker! A busy bus heading out of Hastings, nice view of the rough English Channel. Perhaps I will be back to do the 98 route which runs inland.
Brighton and Hove 12X Eastbourne to Brighton Gemini
After a short pitstop in Eastbourne time to head West again. The Eastbourne to Seaford section was new to me and very impressive, will have to come back to visit beachy head. After Seaford we ran in convey with two other 12 variants. I had my sights on a connection to the Metrobus 271 at the Old Steine.
Stagecoach 17 Brighton to Horsham E300
I decided to catch a late running service 17 to Horsham, a pleasant run through rural Sussex. At Horsham I toyed of the idea of getting the bus to Crawley but I settled for the train.
Metrobus 98 Horsham to Horsham station E200
Decided to take the lazy option up to Horsham station which was a well presented E200. From Horsham Railway station I took the next Southern service to Crawley. I had lunch Crawley and a break of just over an hour
Metrobus 271 Crawley to Brighton via Haywards Heath Double Decker unsure of type 09 plate.
Decided to take the 271 as I have already travelled on the 273 via Hickstead, still to do the 272 and 270. This route gives sweeping views across Sussex before a tootle through Haywards Heath. I jumped off on London Road in Brighton before catching a busy Southern service back along the coast.
Hope to explore further the Metrobus network, such as the routes to Epsom, Dorking and Leatherhead. In addition head further East from Hastings using buses and trains.
Another great trip. The 99 is almost entirely run by deckers, I think you were very unlucky to get an E300. But it isn't massively scenic. The 98 is an alternative with different scenery for another trip.
The 12X is much better. If you do it again, or for anyone else, then it is worth stopping off at a number of places and the service is frequent enough that this isn't difficult. Seven Sisters (the gap where you cross the Cuckmere river), Seaford (sea front), Newhaven (harbour), Rottingdean (sea front) are all worth a stop. For Beachy Head you need the 13X which only runs on Sundays at the moment, there may be a better service in the summer. From Beachy Head you can walk down towards Eastbourne where there is a regular service into town from virtually the bottom of the footpath - I do recommend doing it this way round!
Here is a recent trip I did to Shropshire/ Herefordshire.
I was inspired to make this excursion for two reasons. Firstly, I wanted to witness how Hereford has performed since the recent withdrawal from city routes by Yeomans. Commercially operated city routes in Hereford were mostly withdrawn by Yeomans in December. Sargeants had expanded slightly since then to cover some new areas. Second, this trip is (mostly) courtesy of Herefordshire County Council due to their current scheme of offering free weekend bus travel within the county.
Starting at Shrewsbury at 1130 to 1244, I caught the 435 by Minsterley Motors to Ludlow. I was aiming to catch the 0930 but, they're one of the few bus operators not accepting contact less payments. That's my fault - I'm normally prepared with cash everytime I am out, especially if I am using smaller bus companies, but not today! It was operated by an unbranded plain white Optare versa - though most vehicles in their fleet do contain basic route info and branding at the top. This was a fairly pleasant journey with an average load.
I had 30 mins break in Ludlow, so I had a wander around the town and saw the castle. Ludlow, like Shrewsbury is a historical town and is a lovely place to visit.
Next bus of the day is at 1315 to 1354, then 1400 to 1443, from Ludlow to Leominster and Hereford. This is operated by Lugg Valley as the 490/492 and the same bus operates through. This was operated by an optare solo, as are most (all?) buses by Lugg Valley and the sister company Yeomans. I paid for a single to the Herefordshire border, then travel beyond there was free. The first part of the route was very quiet, I was the only one on board for most of the way, but it got substantially busier on the 492 towards Hereford. There was about 12 on board at the end.
My original plan would have got into Hereford 2 hours earlier - and my schedule thereafter would have been to sample some of the Hereford City local services before heading back to Shrewsbury by train. I decided to instead do something different , after about 90 min break in Hereford, I will head to Knighton via Kington and catch the train to Shrewsbury from there instead. Hereford itself was busy and energetic today, not only was there a market on, there was also a band in town playing a hodgepodge of 80s music.
I got to see a collection of local buses while I was in Hereford. Yeomans and Lugg Valley both look and feel very basic. They have a very drab cream-coloured livery which I do not find particularly eye-catching. My impression is they're a company cutting as many of the costs as possible when providing a service and running a business. They were functional during my trip down from Ludlow to Hereford, but certainly nothing impressive. The passenger numbers I witnessed on city routes also reflect this. The minimalistic attitudes by some bus companies, unfortunately, do very little to encourage any new bus users. It tends to be those who -have- to use the bus rather than those who -want- to.
I caught the 461 by Sargeants to Kington at 1600 to 1710. This was by far the busiest bus I had with around 30 on board, about half getting off at Weobley and half getting off at Kington. The bus continues to Llandrindod Wells - but at Kington the driver said those going further must change. I'm unsure if this was the norm or not. This was also probably the nicest and most varied route of the day with its scenery. I arrived into Kington around 10 mins early.
I also changed buses here, to catch the 41 1730 to 1805 Kington to Knighton, also by Sargeants. It was starting to get dark now, so I didn't get to see much on this route, but it was quick and covered the 10 miles or so in half an hour.
All in all, I had an interesting trip. Compared to Yeomans and Lugg Valley, Sargeants appear to be more ambitious. They have expanded in Hereford City to cover the recent cutbacks by Yeomans. Their fleet presentation is also, in my opinion, more aesthetically pleasant compared to the other company. Their buses are red. They now operate city routes A and B, and 88, running one-way only loops of suburbs, as well as hourly routes from Hereford to Credenhill and Kington. Yeomans local routes are now mostly confined to South of the city, whereas Sargeants have a bit more geographic coverage now.
Hope this was an interesting read.
This is a fabulous trip in a really scenic area and it is a shame that you had to do some of it in the dark. Interesting to hear your take on the situation in Hereford. When I last went Yeomans looked like they were trying reasonably hard to maintain a professional presence and run reliably, but it does seem like services have reduced and Sargents have got a foothold in the Hereford city position now.
The 461 from Hereford to Weobley, Kington and Llandrindod Wells is very scenic and seems to be well run and popular and continues to run at a decent frequency. On one of my first trips I presented myself at Kington Bus Station and Sargent's double decker, then an Optare Spectra, arrived showing Llandrindod Wells - that would have been really good. But the driver dropped off passengers and said that our bus would be along in a minute. It was a Solo. Later I started a trip from Hereford and took the same journey, the same decker after having brought lots of students into the college, and again it finished at Kington, this time I was going on to Knighton on the 41. This position remains, the first journey to and from Hereford and one or two others are normally run by Sargent's Optare MetroDecker now, but not beyond Kington. More recently still I did the whole route with a break for an hour in Weobley, a very scenic village best seen by alighting and exploring, again we changed onto a Solo for the last leg beyond Kington. The last section from Kington to Llandrindod is exceptionally scenic.
The 41 from Kington to Knighton via Presteigne is also very attractive and, as you did it in the dark, I suggest another trip sometime. You could do Shrewsbury - X75 - Llangurig - X47 - Llandrindod - 461 - Kington - 41 - Knighton - 738/740 - Ludlow - 435 - Shrewsbury. That starts at 09.25 and finishes around 19.00 - it gives you an hour and a half in Kington which can easily be filled by walking on the hills just outside the town centre, this is a town where time has stood still and also popular with Mike Oldfield fans (one for the oldies!). Alternatively if you can get to Welshpool for 07.48 or Newtown for 08.30 you can do the same trip running earlier with slightly better connections and including half an hour in Llanidloes.