• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

DLR B23 Stock (CAF Inneo)

Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Geeves

Established Member
Joined
6 Jan 2009
Messages
2,322
Location
Rochdale
I did see the post about them "having to slow them down" but not much more detail than that.

My question is are they accelerating so fast that the CBTC cannot handle it? Its not a problem I have ever heard of and surely they can just slow them down? I mean the CBTC is about as well as established as you could hope and it used by various other railways around the world and London too.
 

TRAX

Established Member
Joined
2 Dec 2015
Messages
1,710
Location
France
I did see the post about them "having to slow them down" but not much more detail than that.

My question is are they accelerating so fast that the CBTC cannot handle it? Its not a problem I have ever heard of and surely they can just slow them down? I mean the CBTC is about as well as established as you could hope and it used by various other railways around the world and London too.
Wasn’t the speed reduction about the current trains (too) ?
 

stuu

Established Member
Joined
2 Sep 2011
Messages
3,395
I did see the post about them "having to slow them down" but not much more detail than that.

My question is are they accelerating so fast that the CBTC cannot handle it? Its not a problem I have ever heard of and surely they can just slow them down? I mean the CBTC is about as well as established as you could hope and it used by various other railways around the world and London too.
You have the wrong end of the stick there. TfL realised that current speeds are slightly too high on some curves, and have reduced the operating speed accordingly by 5km/h in those locations. It may well have been discovered during testing for the new units, but it applies to all the trains
 

Geeves

Established Member
Joined
6 Jan 2009
Messages
2,322
Location
Rochdale
Thanks Stuu, I was just responding that I thought it was only the new trains!

I guess that cannot be an issue then with the CAF trains and we will remain none the wiser ha! I am sure they will figure it out
 

DGP

Member
Joined
31 Mar 2024
Messages
56
Location
London
Agreed. Delayed indefinitely doesn’t mean it will be years we’ll be waiting but no way they’re here before the end of the year.

That timeline seems reasonable but I wonder if the B90/B92 stock can last that long before they need to be expensively overhauled or taken out of service.
 

Snow1964

Established Member
Joined
7 Oct 2019
Messages
8,060
Location
West Wiltshire
TfL Board Programmes and Investment committee papers now available, on page 20 of report (page 47 of pack) says none will be introduced this year.

Mentions the legacy signalling and going to fast, and also software update. Says do have a programme for new train introduction, but needs to be stress tested....

Sorry unable to copy the pdf report format text on my device

 

Thirteen

Established Member
Joined
3 Oct 2021
Messages
1,506
Location
London
That timeline seems reasonable but I wonder if the B90/B92 stock can last that long before they need to be expensively overhauled or taken out of service.
I think if the delay is only a few months, they can just revise the timetable somewhat, there is no chance they'll overhaul the B90/92s.
 

Snow1964

Established Member
Joined
7 Oct 2019
Messages
8,060
Location
West Wiltshire
KeolisAmey have been given a franchise extension from 1st April 2025 until 2033. Mentions introducing 54 new trains

The new agreement, starting on 1 April 2025, will continue the joint venture’s 10-year franchise on the route.

The 40-kilometre automated metro line serves five London boroughs. KeolisAmey will be supporting TfL with the introduction of 54 new trains to the network and making enhancements to the timetable for passengers. A new apprenticeship scheme will also be launched, and sustainable community outreach projects developed with local communities across east and south-east London.

The company also will adopt new technologies based on artificial intelligence within operational delivery and new systems to enhance maintenance regimes and techniques designed to improve customer experience and security and protect revenue.

 

JCO1406

Member
Joined
28 May 2024
Messages
62
Location
Essex
The ones I require are 03 and 42.
Just checking that these aren't long term OOU or similar
Don't get to go to London that often but when I do my trick is to spend aprox 50 mins at Poplar ( enough time to see all sets on Beckton and Canary Wharf) then move to Canning Town for 1/2 hr downstairs (Stratford Intl services) then back over to Canary Wharf for about 45 mins (Lewisham Units)
Next trip may be in December (or maybe November)
Just saw 03 at Beckton a few minutes ago, still running around fine
 

Taunton

Established Member
Joined
1 Aug 2013
Messages
11,087
There's a noticeable service reduction this week, ostensibly because of engineering works for expanding the Beckton depot preventing trains getting out. Various notices around, mostly stating just generally "a reduction", and of course for more information go to TfL website or App. Unfortunately when you do so there is exactly the same sentence, word-for-word. Nothing more ...

One hears that the account a few weeks ago of speed limitations on the system, which sounded a bit strange, was actually about timings for brake applications etc, which had worked fine for a generation with the current stock, not being good enough for the new stock, and they may have had an overrun in the trials. As the system will now be handling both types of trains, it was necessary to extend out some timings by a few seconds at various stops, to allow the system to handle both existing stock and their new, weaker brethren.
 

alholmes

Member
Joined
4 Jun 2012
Messages
430
Location
London E3
Received an email from TfL today advising new DLR timetable to be introduced next Monday, 4th November.

”The new timetable will restore the direct peak hour services between Stratford and Lewisham, which were removed after the initial review. Some services that previously terminated at Canning Town will also be extended to Stratford International.

The new timetable will accommodate the speed restrictions that have been put in place while returning services to broadly the same levels as before, although some journeys will still take slightly longer than before the restrictions were introduced.”


Hopefully it will mean services are more regular. Recently the Stratford - Canary Wharf has become fairly irregular, presumably not helped by the single track sections. Though a train on average every 5 minutes is still good even if it’s sometimes been 2 minutes then 8 minutes recently.
 

stuu

Established Member
Joined
2 Sep 2011
Messages
3,395
One hears that the account a few weeks ago of speed limitations on the system, which sounded a bit strange, was actually about timings for brake applications etc, which had worked fine for a generation with the current stock, not being good enough for the new stock, and they may have had an overrun in the trials. As the system will now be handling both types of trains, it was necessary to extend out some timings by a few seconds at various stops, to allow the system to handle both existing stock and their new, weaker brethren.
Not quite, they discovered that the trains had been running slightly faster than they should have for the braking curve, and going round corners a couple of mph too fast. It was discovered during testing of the new trains but it doesn't seem to be because of them, as such. One might imagine that the fact no DLR train had jumped off the tracks might be a good reason to assume that the braking curve was too restrictive in the first place, but that would be far too sensible
 

JCO1406

Member
Joined
28 May 2024
Messages
62
Location
Essex
Received an email from TfL today advising new DLR timetable to be introduced next Monday, 4th November.

”The new timetable will restore the direct peak hour services between Stratford and Lewisham, which were removed after the initial review. Some services that previously terminated at Canning Town will also be extended to Stratford International.

The new timetable will accommodate the speed restrictions that have been put in place while returning services to broadly the same levels as before, although some journeys will still take slightly longer than before the restrictions were introduced.”


Hopefully it will mean services are more regular. Recently the Stratford - Canary Wharf has become fairly irregular, presumably not helped by the single track sections. Though a train on average every 5 minutes is still good even if it’s sometimes been 2 minutes then 8 minutes recently.

If I'm reading this correctly, the Beckton-Canning Town services will be extended to Stratford Int? Good to hear they're sorting out the speed issues quickly. Hopefully this means that the new trains can start service soon.
 

Thirteen

Established Member
Joined
3 Oct 2021
Messages
1,506
Location
London
I'd be surprised if the B23s are in service this year, I would have thought Spring 2025 was more likely.
 

DGP

Member
Joined
31 Mar 2024
Messages
56
Location
London
If I'm reading this correctly, the Beckton-Canning Town services will be extended to Stratford Int? Good to hear they're sorting out the speed issues quickly. Hopefully this means that the new trains can start service soon.

Just to amplify what others have said, the speed issue is to do with the current trains, it's just the issue was apparently identified whilst testing the new trains. The speed restrictions will remain in place and become the "norm" for both the existing and new trains whenever they do eventually enter service.
 

StratfordP

Member
Joined
12 May 2022
Messages
13
Location
London
Looks from journey planners that they are planning to run some DLR services just to pudding mill lane… presumably to get around inevitable congestion at Stratford with the new timetable?
 

TheManWho

Member
Joined
15 Jul 2010
Messages
138
Looks from journey planners that they are planning to run some DLR services just to pudding mill lane… presumably to get around inevitable congestion at Stratford with the new timetable?
Having checked TfL Journey Planner, I can't see any trains terminating at Pudding Mill Lane. Stratford 4A/4B can handle a 4-5 minute service.
 

JCO1406

Member
Joined
28 May 2024
Messages
62
Location
Essex
If I'm reading this correctly, the Beckton-Canning Town services will be extended to Stratford Int? Good to hear they're sorting out the speed issues quickly. Hopefully this means that the new trains can start service soon.
I can confirm that the Beckton - Canning Town services have been extended to Stratford International
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3420.png
    IMG_3420.png
    152.3 KB · Views: 69

stadler

Established Member
Joined
5 Jun 2023
Messages
1,419
Location
Horsley
If anyone is interested in hearing the new automated announcements voice used on the DLR B23 Stock (and LU 2024 Stock too) she can be heard here in this article published today:


It is a synthetic Text To Speech voice but sounds very good and it is hardly noticeable that she is TTS and not an actual voiceover artist.
 

Vexed

Member
Joined
12 Jan 2020
Messages
271
Location
Herts / Hants
It is a synthetic Text To Speech voice but sounds very good and it is hardly noticeable that she is TTS and not an actual voiceover artist.
Compared to a voice artist it's fine, but it sounds like it's been done in the same way where they "record" short tracks which are then stiched together (the first recording has some timing issues near the end). It would sound a lot better if the TTS was generated live so the gaps between words, intonations, and other speech features dependent on the previous/next word flow better. The actual voice is fine though, it doens't sound robotic.

I appreciate generating the same text live every time is pointless, but they could at least generate normal stopping patterns from each station as one continuous flow. Then fall back to stitching station names together if there are any changes.
 

JCO1406

Member
Joined
28 May 2024
Messages
62
Location
Essex
I assume there will be some further testing happening with the new timetable over the next few weeks. Hopefully they announce a new EIS date soon.
 

DGP

Member
Joined
31 Mar 2024
Messages
56
Location
London
Given these speed restrictions have now become permanent, I was pleasantly surprised to see the re-introduction of the peak Stratford to Lewisham service. I was more surprised, with the need to reduce the mileage on the older stock, to see the extension of the Beckton to Canning Town service to Stratford International. I wonder if this means the DLR are confident about introducing the new trains soon? And if so, would this Beckton to Stratford International service be the perfect place to "soft launch" them before introducing them on the busier routes?
 

JCO1406

Member
Joined
28 May 2024
Messages
62
Location
Essex
Given these speed restrictions have now become permanent, I was pleasantly surprised to see the re-introduction of the peak Stratford to Lewisham service. I was more surprised, with the need to reduce the mileage on the older stock, to see the extension of the Beckton to Canning Town service to Stratford International. I wonder if this means the DLR are confident about introducing the new trains soon? And if so, would this Beckton to Stratford International service be the perfect place to "soft launch" them before introducing them on the busier routes?
I don't think that they will start rolling out this year. Most likely January/February if TFL is ready for them. I agree with what you said about the Beckton-Stratford Int service. My guess is that the first lot will be mainly on the Beckton routes, considering its close proximity and ease of access to Beckton Depot if needed to be taken out of service.
 

Thirteen

Established Member
Joined
3 Oct 2021
Messages
1,506
Location
London
Probably better to roll them out during a quieter travel period than peak Christmas season.
 

Top